early on she was like oh we're going to sing live and uh I was like no we're not or you you you can sing live if you'd like but I'm and ultimately we did yeah and it and it was really the only way I mean that not only did we sing live but um every part of the recording was was live we didn't sing to completed tracks or to click track we're working with a Pianist um you know on set so each each take was a different version of of the song and of singing the song um so that felt really exciting I think created an energy that was was necessary at least that I I felt