30-08-2024 - COURT OF HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE NIRZAR S. DESAI, GUJARAT HIGH COURT

of you must have seen the board outside up to 12:30 fresh matters 12:30 police protection fresh matters up to 49 12:30 police protection matter 12:45 bail application 230 registration of F and 330 up to 250 release of mudal page wise mentioning yes 14-year-old boy was brutally beaten and abused whatever the things why are you not registering the f are you registering it or not not affidavit register the F otherwise I'm issuing notice for contempt of Lita Kumari judgment law serial number three CH are you registering the F or not ask him to be here then yes now file reply in that contemp procedings once I issue notice in contempt 15 if you want time just give cheat no need to mention 34 35 number 44 I seek permission to withdraw this petition Lord with the Liberty to file concern caution petition in this matter I have made an application for joining he's withdrawing why are you OB this petition itself is with consent if they are withdrawing simply I have no objection but if the papers are seen affid of the complainant is there it is a conspiracy to show some of the accused as a Bonafide person and my client as a culprate this is the conspiracy this application is not maintainable it has been filed by accused yes therefore my application itself says that I am the SC go made by those people when that application is heard you can always object today he is filing thee preferring to withdraw this application with a view to Fresh application you can as and when that fresh application is preferred you can object that application no difficulty at but this petition itself is for consent of the page for his petition if he wants to withdraw with whatever reason for whatever reason what objection you can have am I passing any order against you not at all but then as in when that time comes you may object my Lord only I'll keep your subm rights also open my Lord may not kindly take note that this petition is also with consent of the complaint affid is there still he wants to withdraw what right you have to object I cannot but only to point out this your objection is in respect of washing of the F or some of the accused persons right I have also filed washing therefore as in when hearing of that application takes place you may do it fresh ption number 44 SC number 5675 of 2024 learned Advocate Mr Adra upon instruction seeks permission to withdraw this petition with a view to file fresh petition with the same prayer permission has prayed for is granted it is clarified that this court has not gone into the mags of the matter next learned Advocate Mr Deepak Patel objects to the withdrawal of this petition as it is contended by Mr Patel that the petition has been withdrawn is sought to be withdrawn with a MiFi intention however if any fresh petition is preferred with the same prayer the petition can raise all possible all the rights and contentions of the applicant of C one of 24 are kept open and he can object to the fresh application that Mr Adra f as may be filed by the applicant as may be filed by the applicant not M and crma will not Sur appliation for joining party also stand dispos 230 230 49 right 49 230 595 no priority will be given CH next 83 serial number 76 is M pertaining to 49 by father so what what is so special about iten up I will not taking up to 1230 whichever numbers are called out I'll take up rest of the matters except for the matters which are already listed in the board will not be taken up that case if it is not reached shter 94 95 to 99 100 to 106 Number 103 father daughter because she the father not possible today no priority don't mention for priority it will not be possible today short after five request the court after five 111 milers matters become infructuous so withraw 111 learned Mr upon instruction seeks permission to withdraw this petition as the same has become infructuous permission has PR for is granted then point out to the thought Master give a cheat it is already there 123 exit priority I said no priority to anyone develop if I'm not taking up the MS where Mr O is appeared I will not take up this as well 119 maybe let that let that order be passed by some other CT 119 not before this C excluded and I have no objection 119 not this sir 128 137 1387 in 144 I have still not received the reply though my Lord categorically informed them to supply me 144 who appears that matter in cor jail when person was B along with registration of f i take I just want to point out this yes I've taken note of it as when it is called out I'll take9 yes 173 174 186 187 27 28 239 after 250 up to 3:35 I'm not going to take up today some date will be given any Friday office objections to be removed on or before 20th September fing which without any further reference2 is to and add not without looking at the matter next if not today then request the registry I will not say anything this is for removal of office objects next yes convince the registry yes Mr supplementary board serial number two yes it is yesterday's matter kep today should The Honorable board consider taking up at 11 or at30 which is consent question supplementary board serial number two why it is kept today yesterday The Honorable Court desired to see the sale deed it's a consent question yes yes should the H3 230 very question circulation for speaking two minutes man Monday please cir reest yes requesting circulation for speaking two minutes Monday basically the recovery proceeding is filed and the matter is listed on 99 you may request for time there request for early listing is not entertained order request is rejected is on 25th and connected matter is today that they requested will not be possible Mr but request is rejected separate yes why why DCP it should be from commissioner you given free hand to your officers to investigate the way he wants only three accused May s and two other unknown person yes so not 425 that is Imagination of your IO unnown during investigation F mentions three name during course of Investigation you may have come to know that the then how can you touch iton take you may take two hours but you will have to justify you can't you can't force a settlement merely because you are police department on 27 May 2022 and 6 June 2022 a monetary transaction came how are you concerned with that lot many people enter into monetary Transaction what was the F for Miss meta and po that transaction the incident of or robbery of the CCTV camera and the footage now the only thing which the officers have found or what I felt which has resulted into the investigation so far is that a conspiracy was HED I'm observing against your offices don't worry let the report come they cannot over the process of law now I'll direct everyone to be ar as accus face that and I if I smell anything fishy I can even investigate I can even direct the matter to be investigated by some Central agency you can't abuse the power like this take instruction are they prepared for CBI inquiry I take instruction Miss MAA are they prepared to face CBI they can't enforce settlement in respect of a land by registering false fi or I may say for a very small issue and thereafter making mountain of a mole you take instruction I'm prepared to interest and I'll give reasons for that take instruction from your commissioner let the report come I'll consider everything Miss MAA take instruction nothing appeals till now why are you dragging yourself into all this it's not about staying it's about abuse of power misuse of power which which I am experiencing day in and day out in various I therefore take instructions are they prepared to face CBI I will because you are abusing power day in and day out and only in land matters anytime a piece of land comes in front of you you are attacking as if a rabbit is attacked by lion I will not pardon let inquiry be held against this off officer you take instruction are you inviting an order I'll entrust everything why every time it happens only in respect of land matters why are you not restraining yourself only to the subject can I you are getting some instruction from learned PP I will not keep it at 2:30 Mr you take it within 10 minutes otherwise I'm prepared to observe everything thing I'll State everything that the man in with the investigation has taken place civil dispute is pending the moment civil court granted State partly allowed the application for exhibit 5 all these things started and be Surat be rajot be vodra wherever there are land prices which are escalating every time you are over trying to over the process of law only in respect of land matters if you want I can call for the registry for the all the fs which are registered in respect of land matters give a list to you and we'll pass separate order in respect of every matter you are trying to pressurize innocent people by enforcing settlement upon them you are arbitrator then ask your commissioner to suspend that officer first come within 10 minutes or I'll call from the registry the list wherein land is involved yes and every time after failing in civil court by of a shortcut polic is in approached yes yes and thereafter they start enforcing settlement they start investigating absolutely in different direction they start making people cap goat are they paying tax for that for that harassment whether this power is given this power is given to this department for harassing people yes and what about serial number three I'm issuing contem notice against your officer are you registering F or not come with an come with an F at 230 or I'm issuing contemp pro pro uh proceedings against your alling officers including commissioner who has not obeyed the order of the Court yes yes on the yes see see I understand using reasonable Force using reasonable Force against hardcore criminal is permissible under law as well but you can't equate you can't equate a 14-year-old boy with a hardcore Criminal mother father why did you take hand in respect of a 14year old boy mother and father's act cannot Shield you when you beat a 14-year old boy you will have to register an f are you registering it or not or are you facing contempt you just take instruction and come back but he makes anation offic of those four offic officers at hospital off there is a record Mr Mr after registration of offense you can investigate you can place all these things on record you can file summary against them you can do whatever you do but first offense must be registered people must not gather an impression that whenever it comes against your own Department you you are putting the cart before horse Mr Mr the Mr the I did not I did not say that register the offense send them to jail you can investigate but first let the common man get an impression that for even smallest reason your officers are not being shielded their grievance their grievance are heard by the people or the people in power who are having power to register the F and you are not blindly shielding them thereafter upon investigation you can say that this is a false F but investigation must take place it's not about Mr Mr the way it's not about it's not about it's not about my it's not about my willingness we all have to follow the dictum of Lita Kumari he was not beaten he was not beaten what par 120 120.4 and 12.6 says that verification shall take place afterwards the moment a plain reading of the grievance of the petitioner or the complainant indicates that this is a primy non-cognizable offense you must register an F cognizable offense yes so according to he was garlanded not beaten then first register it set an example that you are ready set an example that you are ready to take action against your own officer as well previously also they have made another Mr Mr let us do one thing I'll call from the registry all the petitions wherein allegations are labeled against police officers you can we can we can fix a specially against the off offense alleged against police department and no no I'm I'm I'm suggesting you something I'll if you are saying that spare this family I'll spare this family and thereafter from 11 to 5 you may examine every single complaint against your department I am on that if I right then if I am right then why in other matters also you are not registering F here you have one result to Shield your officers what about other matters I I also yes but let us let us fix all the matters on a particular day you suggest me the date like we have done it in the remission matters you come with every f i I'm repeating it's not about my personal wish it's about respecting the Judgment of Lita Kumari by all of us and and what about if if all these atrocities are done to a juvenile 14y old boy today it's someone's son tomorrow it may be My Son Your Son Mr Jan is we have to see an overall picture we cannot say that this is an exceptional case this is not an exceptional case we cannot give free hand to this department like this otherwise someday we all will be a victim of their brutal force their activities must be kept in check and your officers Prime off his it seems have failed to do that so take instruction in both the matters of the M whenever you want Tuesday number three yes yes come with the come come with suspension order at 230 no action like iOS action must be loud clear and strict so that it can set an example and other officers will think 100 time before doing any illegality yes yes straight way I I'll give reasons if you are inviting an order I'll give reasons for suspending such officers suspension bring that procedure bring that procedure by 12:30 let us find a way out sup doesn't require any yes for inquiry after suspension within within 90 days or 120 days Char sheet is required to be given that is the law and you will have to set an example against officers who are acting dishonestly Prime officy no no no 230 you will have to take instruction for what have you what have you done from yesterday evening to today take instruction Miss MAA I'm not going to spare anyone yes all of us want to live in peaceful atmosphere not in this kind of atmosphere everyone will feel that there is a threat looming large one on him tomorrow police will call and ask him to come to police station and why it is happening everywhere in land mats only why you are proactive in land matteress only very well otherwise I wouldn't mind granting not one two but 20 reasons for yes yes sh here due to lising of one matter in the honorable Apex Court Mr n had to travel here due to listing of an matter in the honorable aex Mr had to travel for a day I'm only requesting for days accommodation Monday please till then may be extended to continue till next yes um Mal this is a speaking two minute note uh the my appearance is shown for the petitioner was in real actually Mr kames kotai appears I am appearing for complainant because there were two matters tag together it appears that this not pointed out by learned Advocate Miss shangi Rana that the name of Miss Rana is shown wrongly as advocate for the petitioner in fact she had appeared for the complainant yes the order is required to be corrected to the not for speaking to minut it is dispos please leave M may I leave I may leave M please m yes this page 14 is the F Meo the f is of the Year 2020 yes for discharge charet is not fil m charet is not fil initially I was shown as a witness in the first chart sheet that is on page 29 sheet who are you what is your role well uh my role is that even as for the allegations I you are rajal andas yes ma'am right is your role from the F I'm not not named in the F initially I was shown as a witness in the first chart sheeet that is at page 29 on as a witness number 13 and 15 after that most the supplementary was charge sheet was filed wherein I was soon as suspected accused in April 2024 we were arrested and we were released on regular bill by The Honorable sence Court Baruch now kindly see page 14 is the F that is the allegation and on P 16 mil yes I'm on page 16 please Milos so these are the allegations against the accuse number one and two who are named in the F so far as my role is concerned mil I was implicated on the basis statement on the basis of statement of Co accuse that is accuse number one and initially on 13th of January 2020 the company has issued a soos notice to the accuse number one and that is at page 20 mil and in on page 20 soos notice was issued and on page 24 that is not issued to you you are not janak no my yes then why are you referring to this shos notice yes because notice is required to be answered by the person who is asked to show cause yes m not that person yes M because in that so notice that janala has accepted his the allegations does it mean that if one person accepts it means that there are no other persons involved because initially before registration of the sorry for that only because yes is it is it in respect of a single person no mil then you are in 120b what do you want for a moment M after that I will not M kindly see page 18 yes it is the body of the f m so internal before registration of the F the company has formed a committee committee has investigated that yes the accuse number one that is Jala has misappropriated the amount and after that my in March 20120 the FI is registered from 2020 to 2024 we were working in the company we have not issued any soos notice after we were swn as a suspected accus in supplementary Char sheet on 6th of April 20124 uh we have been served with the soos notice we have replied to them another notice was ised we were suspended because we were in a custody for almost 10 days MOS therefore we were suspended from the yes does not mean that no offense is made out against you what do you want you want a reasoned order then I'll record your submission and pass the order because even as per because we were in the working in a back office m not we have not to the trial and get the equital if you are inocent because even the CH sheet is not filed against us maybe I'm not directing them to file charge sheet I'm just assessing your Ro and make observations about your Ro that how that safire is rightly filed against you even as per the SOP of the company milot we are working in a finance and audit Department yes and on page 335 you want to have access to that no what do you want for a moment on page 335 we are working in finance and audit Department our role is to enter the data only which were provided by the uh accused number one that is lead C and M that is our role only and are therefore after investigating after taking due care you have been AR as accused now earlier you as witness yes ma' there after you are suspected accused and now you are accused so it's not that overnight you are made accused after Gathering the evidence against you after collecting it from various Corners you have now is Accused what do you want so that I not press does not press this application with a VI to file appropriate application once Char sheet is filed appropriate application before appropriate Pine yes M apart from miles and M in the present case even 379 is not made out for the reason we not that uh he is a person who has given his vehicle on rent to third person that documents are on record even he was out of station we have produced everything on record he are of evidence as far as minds and minerals acts are concerned I'll protect you please her learned Advocate missa for the petitioner Misha points out from the F that f is registered apart from section 379 114 of IPC under Section 3 and 21 of Gujarat mineral into bracket illegal mining transportation and storage bracket work rules 2005 2016 and 2017 according to Misha section 21 of the Gujarat mines and minerals into bracket regulation and development act provides for a complaint in writing by the authorized officer and as the f is not registered and it cannot be to be a complaint in writing by the offer officer the F ought not to have been registered under relevant provisions of Gujarat minerals into bracket illegal mining transportation and storage rules 2005 2016 and 2017 accordingly she prays for staying the proceedings of the f as far as it is in respect of the provisions of garat mineral rules M also places on record and Order dated 28 2024 passed by this court in criminal Miss application number 156 of 24 whereby in similar set of effects this court had granted to the petitioner of that petition for the offens is punishable under relevant provisions of mines and minerals act 1957 next accordingly in view of that issue notice to the respon FS returnable on so and so date in the meantime there shall be add in terms of per it would be S small B 7B only in respect of offense under Section 3 and 21 of Gujarat mineral into bracket prevention of illegal mining transportation and storage rules 2005 2016 and 2017 direct service perit grateful to much highly oess so far as this matter is concerned I need a week's time Ed to produce on record the documents from next week know will yes and 22 simar this is that where is the order this is the order same order but very minor modification which have made by by canceling the lines which are different otherwise in seven that is the order and in 22 the order at page 56 this another f is also not in respect of cup syrup you it's uh why canc it's in respect of the C syrup covered by Central drugs laboratory but different cuup syrup because four C syrups are involved very well 21 only in s and number 5 7 is 16938 yes a seven sudar 22 page number 56 super produ 22 page number 56 identically identical verum same order off SE 376 Ando after attaining the marriageable age or 18 years both have got married Lord both are present before this honorable Court page number foring consent cing consent fi is filed by the father so it will not be consent but victim is present yes I did not ask anyone to remain remain present mil are keeping on some Thursday Mr vij AAR Mr jish AAR as instructions to appear on behalf of the respond number three I have made victim respond number three register to accept his VP and other documents that you may file this can also be go on any Thursday because this is a constant watching only my leared friend may be appear your your name D Tak dhik Tak same order Mr dhik Tak only request is on 12th the trial court proceedings is there so can it time on that day please my Lord the matter is for the police protection as the other side the persons are there they are continuously harassing on Jes pel and other persons they're having good political relations and police relations and along with the police of the kba police station he is helping them and they are harassing him to by of this petition the petitioner has prayed for directing the respond number two and three to provide police protection to the petitioner against the accus in respect of his application dated 16824 coning the application of the coning the fact that the application preferred by the petitioner is pending respond number two and three are D Pi kova police station is directed to consider the petitioner application dated 16824 and pass appropriate order about pass appropriate order on the same the order may be communicated to the petitioner by of rpad the decision may be taken as early as possible preferably within a month with this observation without entering into the merits of the matter petition is disposed on Service Direct service yes you are misusing your power in respect of land matters let the what necessary action why I am I am not considering you may carry this order Mr you may carry this order to The Honorable Supreme Court I passing that order it must stop somewhere I will not no no I have given sufficient time I'm conducting this kind of matter since 9th of June and this must be at least 20th matter of this nature there must be some and to even patience that is what I'm passing the order you may carry it no no you will have to buy 230 if you if you are suspending him by 230 I will not sign the order or else I'll will sign the order I'm making observations against give the name of commissioner DCP whosoever who have spoken to you give their name that they have refused they only request no no no request then they must they must respect the sentiment of the court and act accordingly give the name of your commissioner us either come I yes I will I will I will note I will note every submission of you and pass this order my simple but only saying is that the report which he submitted appears to be more on the L side than [Music] on you may you may suspend him today and reinstate him tomorrow but you will have to suspend him Mage must go loud and clear that no such illegality will be permitted by the court your officer May permit I will not permit so give name of commissioner DCP whosoever instructed you I'll mention everything in my order this that what I I not personally in the there is nothing personal me you Mr n Mr or Mr J the report he had submitted what I told is that it is reproduction of F I verified f is only f is only one page report was consisting of six pages he says that in is only mentioned and therefore leave it on me I consider your submission and give my reasons for issuing direction to m is being mentioned in the F therefore and and and I'm and I'm also directing the registry that on one day all the matters pertaining to land and another day all the matters pertaining to your department you suggest the date if if your officers are so stubborn then they must do it if they are not stubborn otherwise every single matter I'll take up and I'll consider Merit of every single matter you must show willingness to Mr whatever I wanted to say i' say yes in the meantime page 22 page 72 also yesterday now I'm referring to kindly see from the my Lear friend has brought that application my directed me to bring that application of 29th July now I will go to this application yes kindly see page 22 last but one paragraph regular case number I'm sorry application 7 7 yes all throughout yes Nar is land issue no no I not on this is addressed to commissioner kindly see first therefore I was inviting page 22 and 23 of the my paper how the context and why they are exiant in taking action I'll just demonstrate it now when they making an issue these application is addressed to Commissioner of police rport now F page 22 says I will go to this application in what by every word I will read but the 22 F last but one paragraph regular di case number page 22 yes last but one paragraph IS F 58 in the context I have shown yesterday that his Poss is not believed by the trial code in this suit page 58 that is why shortcut therefore after this now page 23 of this very f andone up to DCP are justifying this action CP I now naming CP and therefore I'm showing all this kindly see we need not trust because he is commissioner number 233 23 yes last four lines yes in the meantime on 20 now now this application becomes relevant yes this is 29th July after the incident before the F yes kindly see paragraph number three onwards even two he is naming me now now before that now Mr get the details about this application also what was the noting of the commissioner because now I'm observing something against him also get all the details Mr Patel by that time get the get the details about from the registry about the matters for registration of f against this department and in commissioner application and against and also the details wherein f is in respect of land matters in this application yes there is no reference to bills received CCTV vendor no ref and why this application per 11 yes here also what he PR is CCT ultimately he says that I am in possession and somebody is disturbing possession either at my instance or at the instance of the parties with whom I have some hidden contract let us take it as it is then also when he is not in lawful possession that is the finding recorded by the civil court at the most he can file a counter suit or cross objection he could file an application for contempt if at all 30 for attempt anything if the breach is being committed nothing of that sort is done only police mer was required to be set in motion nothing Forge was found and now everyone in One Voice are protecting him protecting on the ground that CCTV Camas are stolen Rob transaction CCTV CA yes if I would sub am to justify that that is what feeling therefore I'm interesting I'm interesting the investigation call Mr P also I'm interesting the investigation to CBI and directing your commissioner or DG IG whosoever by recording that they have failed to protect the interest of a common man and this IO must be suspended do you want to say anything so that you may not feel that you are not heard yes I will not I will I want action action which a common man must feel that they have taken against their own officer for doing wrong you cannot keep protecting your officers Mr Mr the had it had it been a solitary incident I would have acceded to your request how many such matters you have appeared in I say today suspend tomorrow you mayate the service record of that PSI off that will inspire what I will give reasons I will I will I will observe I will observe that this swata Aban is required in this department I will obser Mr once you are inviting Mr no I will not consider any single request because I have given you a chance either invite the order or obey the order then then make a statement then make a statement I will not tolerate all these kind of things in land matters sometime that is what up to 2:30 tomorrow morning no tomorrow we are on holiday court is not functioning tomorrow 2:30 ask your commissioner DG IG whoever highest officer this will not be tolerated no no soever thing is that this must stop somewhere everyday people must not approach this court with a grievance against your officers and the conduct in the manner in which the investigations are being conducted and every time whenever something comes your higher officers shuts their eyes they do nothing except pacifying the court and most of the time it is at their instructions subordinate officers are working but it is like you will have you will have to take Stern action against your officers yes yes because I am of that view he's shielding your airing officers who is that name me join him I will join I will either come with order of suspension or invite the order 230 protecting see protecting protecting will only will only satisfy his grievance what about what about other common men who are fac ing similar treatment from your department this may not be the solitary incident by this IO yes your duty your duty first is not towards your subordinates but towards people who have whatever little confidence left in your system right this order what propos people see no a teech in time saves nine if a strong order is passed today it will prevent at least 50 other people from being victimized by the Airing officers so don't look at an individual look at it overall impact of the order it may not happen that to save the N that the one who is at the hand but therefore but therefore I'm prepared to give reasons I have reasons see Mr Mr Mr the in how many matters have taken this yes I every time when land matter comes the in dispute land dispute unnecessary this is happening I understand but that the system can be created not by no there is already a circular issue long back that in land matters police should not wear civil are pending where is what is to that circular are they reading it before therefore once the Mr the similarity similarity in this case and case of Surat is that a small officer may not be interested in taking the aair but the moment Commissioners are approached Everything Changes Everything Changes upside down and therefore it is time for passing an order because officer would not register an F the complant will approach the see registration Mr registration of f is never a problem it's always a welcome sign it's it's the manner in which the investigation has taken place investigation for my as well as report side by side he had mentioned was see your report says how much how many time you have taken this much pain in respect of P offences why is investigating some extra miles he's going extra and investigating something which is not expected in such kind of small offenses just to connect the petitioner to that offense what is the grievance in the F and in this complaint Mar CCTV camera show me the instances everyone everyone would require a pawn therefore if you are inviting an order I'll ENT the entire investigation to CBI let everything come on record because then then that agency then that agency will ask for call records of everyone higher officer lower officer complainant petitioner everyone I for Monday but not then at least 230 230 as a last chance on Monday so that no appropriate number of time this last chances are given they they keep on doing the same thing last chance can be given only provided your highest officer files an affid before this court that in land matters they will not arrest anyone without sufficient evidence or ar as accuse as it's it may be XYZ I'm not saying petitioner complainant whosoever but they must take due care in land matters and they whenever the civil litigation is pending they must not touch beyond the F that is what they are supposed to do but they are not doing they are they are they are not doing and this officer must be taken to task that that because it is their duty to do that it is not something which they are not supposed to and your your commissioner must Ender apology in writing in that case if he wants his suspension to be saved let your commissioner file an affidavit apologizing is he prepared I I will take instruction on that because he will not proba he's the head of he's the head of the district he's then if he's not aware then it is even worse I'm not saying I'm just you being a PP you are aware about every single matter right if if you are so if if you are so maticulous why your commissioner can't be so so either either either either come with his apology in writing or allow to pass that order I will ENT the investigation to CBI I'll direct that IO to be suspended yes can't harest people like this yes please my complaint is on page seven sir given to both commissioner as well as the Police Inspector for registration of aair of an offense which is narrated in detail in the said complaint my Lord man to for different people you have different yard stick for registration of F that is the problem look page eight onwards the entire detail is given how they came what the payment they have made after taking material worth more than 5 CR and how much they paid when we started asking yesterday one of the consent cting was in respect of around 40,000 rupees wor worth Goods F was registered here it is 2 45 lakhs yes anur and Jewel where are the a please mam page four page ground C ground C entered into settlement agreement to amicably resolve the dispute within 10 days however no genuine efforts have been made so then you enforce the settlement agreement file appropriate application or I'll I'll pass that usual order my Lord may just see my application yes I'm passing that usual order please and some time bound no no time bound Pi Maura police station application dated 27524 you appeared for Mr Amit sir yes I AC next he also deed maybe that's not your Lookout no I just mentioned in my complt in detail deeply o direct service may be given so that at least will come in the order the allegations are that the complainant have purchased some plots and the co accused that is accus number two has also purchased the same plots therefore the allegations are that that that accuse has created the both documents in uh the form of share certificate like that page 18 is the cing petition the order passed by my Lord in the washing petition filed by the purchaser allegations against me is that I have purchased the those plots from this Anil sha in fact I have not purchased any plots I not in position I'm making statement that I I am not even uh claiming any right title or interest on the plots one more land matter see I made accuse f land matter yeah I will pass that order but question is why every time you are so fast in registering F in respect of land matters and why are you after those people who are ear as accused you don't have any other interest in registering any other offenses py offenses you don't register but whenever you find that land worth crores of Rupees is involved you are very fast in registering the offense and in investigating the matter what is so special about these land matters learned Advocate Mr Deepak Patel for the petitioner learned Advocate Mr Patel states that though the petitioner has not purchased any plot lot in respect of land mentioned in the f he has been AR as an accuse in the F yes I am the Manish I am shown that I have purchased these plots from Anil sha who has been protected by my law in fact I have not purchased any plot I am making statement that I will not even claim any title interest or position only because I am known to this Anish sha or some other accused I made and accur learned Advocate Mr Deepak Patel upon instruction makes a statement that petitioner only knows who accuse Anil Sha but he has not purchased any plot either in the past or hold any post any plots or holds any plot in the a fored scheme at present nor in the future he shall claim any right title or interest over the plot in question he also Drew attention of this court that the said Mr Anil wal sha who is the accuse number two preferred special criminal application number 8263 of 24 before this court and he has been protected by this court who I order it at 5824 and therefore the petitioner being accused number three and it is alleged that he has purchased the Brad plot from the said Co accused Mr Anil sha he also is required to be protected in view of above submission issue notice to the response returnable on so and so date in the meantime there shall be add in terms of per 8B service permitted 8 uh yes Lord but it may be heard with that matter so that both can be very be heard with special criminal application number 8263 of 24 DS through conern police station number two to be served through conern police station I'm obl this first of is page number 13 man page number 13 3 13 13 yes page number 14 sause number two my for the co my Lord has passed order at page number 14 in my in same C 40 40 49 49 49 this is for the co accus section 22 bar is which is the next date next date is my lord9 dat Mr Patel 15320 of 24 special criminal application next Jo be 320 15320 of 24 to be heard with criminal Miss application number 15320 of 202 get the outside it was pointed out by learned ADV Mr abishek Kuman for Mr dougle that the co accuse in the same a is protected by this court wide order dated 8824 passed in criminal misss application number 15320 of 24th and there the court has by of headen State the further proceedings in respect of offenses under the provisions of mines and minerals into bracket development and regulation act 1957 in view of above issue notice to the response returnable on so and so date 29th October in the meantime by of page 50 last paragraph to be heard with special CRI sorry criminal Misan application number 15320 of 24 there is one other matter page number 51 one other there tot two accus already passed by my very well please your look took place on 287 2023 I have gone before the police station on 1 823 the p is for for registration of an Empire uh the uh incident is like this L on 26723 one heaviest purpose petition was filed by the akanga uh C has filed this application and on 28723 the matter was on the board 498 498 D see took away the child from uh my daughter-in-law has took away the child from me so that is the incident took place on uh 28723 many of times I have gone before the police station rightly not registered it's a civil dispute domestic dispute the custody I'll add the most direct the authority to consider your application CH Police Inspector Bak police station application dated uh8 23 and the second is 6823 1823 and 68823 three uh just one observation what no observation if you want I may dismiss it right away consider theid no on page number 14 is the app husband is not before my law who is before the court husband no my law mother-in-law and sister-in-laws General allegations Mr jiger Patel for Mr for the petitioner Mr Patel from the F points out that there are allegations of General nature against the present petitioner who are mother-in-law and sister-in-law of the complainant and therefore they are required to be protected as the same are made just to abuse and misuse of process of law considering the for submissions issue notice to the response returnable on so and so in the meantime there shall be ident in terms of par and so 15 15 15 C 15 c d is permitted number two to be served through concern Poli yes m the issue as such is very short history of the litigation is little long therefore kindly not the dates I just on 11414 2014 complaint there are developments which have taken place and now the LA laid down by the three judges bch of The Honorable Supreme Court in the case of ifes kindly permit me to produce the Judgment yes Mayes May kindly straight go to page 239 of the compiler 239 yes yes paragraph 187 on the top yes in light of the above analysis we now proceed necessary I'll take to the discussion in the Judgment we now proceed to summarize our conclusion on seminal points in issue in the following terms now others are not relevant laes May kindly see Mal's last D that is 5D 187 5D the offense under Section 3 of 2002 Act is dependent on illegal gain of property as a result of criminal activity relating to a schedule offense it is concerning the process or activity connected with such property which constitutes the offense of money laundering the authorities under under the 2002 act cannot prosecute any person on notional basis or on an assumption that a schedule offense has been committed unless it is so registered with the jurisdictional police and or pending inquiry trial including by way of criminal complaint before the competent for if the person is finally discharged acquitted or the scheduled offense of the schedule offense all the criminal case against him is sashed by the court of competent jurisdiction there can be no offense of money laundering against him or anyone claiming such property being the property link uh to to State schedule offense through him now here the facts are little peculiar I'll just narrate in brief what has happened that in 2014 a complaint is filed mot by The Authority M Ed Under the pmla prior there to a schedule offense M was already registered three months before although that soon by before the DCB police station now there I am shown the petitionary shown as a prime witness against the main accus first Char is file the prime accused was not arranged as the accuse against toots I have deposed before the police in the second chart that Prime accus M who is shown as accuse number one m has been ared as the accused and my statement m is considered by the investigating agency I'm mot projected as the star witness and ultimately mot the investigation was going now that Prime accuse mot made an application uh before the London magistrate that this summons which is issued against the m is wrongly issued ultimately the matter M had come before the high court in revision and mot revision was allowed by The Honorable High Court mot in 2017 where in mot it is held that the summons issued against the main accused Prime accused m is wrong that matter is Cared by the state of Gujarat to The Honorable Supreme the Judgment if you is kindly see which I have annexed not in that compilation that is annexed in with our petition page 90 90 90 Milos may just see the title state of Gujarat MOS versus so and so yes page 90 yes and the relevant paragraph youres will find page 29 uh page 107 per 2 whereby mot in revision dishonorable Court the Lear single judge M has sash the summons against the prime accused and the entire proceedings were dropped against it as far as the schedule offense is concerned now kindly see m per 15.4 15.4 29 yes in par 15 learned single OB in par 15.4 the Learned single judge observed that the respondent accuse is neither director nor any authorized person for any of these seven companies and there is neither any allegation that any of these companies were formed and controlled by the responded accuse nor that the bank accounts of any of these companies were managed by the respondent accuse that is accuse Motu his name here again the Learned single judge add in proceeding against uh presump presumptive footing that the entire transaction is a simple case of presentation of fake bills of entry and ently inducing ICI Bank to remit the foreign exchange to foreign companies for import of Diamonds though presenting forced and fake bills of Entry would be an important Last Leg of the transaction the respondent accused is allegedly involved in the earlier part the collective collection of money that is by collecting money from remitters and the respondent accus and his person Amit elas Bilal Haron gilani sending it to PR B Patel but is the petitioner and his person Amit elas Bilal harun gilani sending into it to pul Patel through angas who in turn transfer the money by rtgs to chain of companies operated by Madan L Jane in icic case of prosecution is that the persons who played any role in this conspiracy to fraud and cheat the government and Banks is equally liable for the offense and not merely the persons who actually forged the signature or stamp of the custom officers in preparing the fake of Entry the lar senior Council for the respond and accuse so and so submitted that angas as well asul Patel would form a vital Link in his flow in this flow of money and therefore they should have been charged it was submitted that the very fact that the angas and trul by Patel are not shown as accused in any of the charge which show that the prosecution case is concerned only about fake bills of entry and not havala as alleged or a or a complex economic offense as AED refuting this contention the Learned Council for the appellant so and so submitted that the role of hrias is only of a crier service that is carrying the cash and the role of purul Patel is to convert black money in cash into white it was submitted that angria as well as pul Patel were certainly participating in the tax Pro by facilitating tax evasion but they may not have been involved in the remittance of the amount in foreign exchange to the foreign companies it was submitted that if and when any evidence of their involvement in the entities controlled by mad L J emerged they would form part of the larger conspiracy and fraud involved in the present case now kindly see my statement is considered by The Honorable Supreme I'm issuing notice two two interesting facts mot which have mots which have been developed mots are this after this judgment of the owner Supreme Court where my statement is considered and The Honorable Supreme Court has also said that my role at the best can be said to be M that of in evasion of tax mot which is I mean for which the income tax department is SPS ultimately mot The Honorable High Court's judgment is cost and satisfied by The Honorable Supreme Court thereafter a third Char is f mil Lord my canly see by the prosecuting agency where MOS after six years in 2020 for the first time from witness mot I was shown as the accused so that my statement gets diluted and M the main accused MOS can get benefit therefore M I have approach this honorable Court MOS by filing a petition all these FS M are narrated in detail ultimately I was protected and as far as M schedule offense is concerned The Honorable M high court has State the proceedings and mes State the summons also issued against me in the third chge after that my lords May kindly see the main accus mord in spite of these observations made by The Honorable Supreme Court has filed an application for discharge before the Lear Chief judicial mist and the Lear Chief judicial magistr M has discharged the M by speaking in spite of these facts M being I'm issuing notice very notice returnable on Direct service permitted I was requesting for some protection in at this stage let the other side appear please I'm that's only only one request in advance I may make that if in caseable date the matter does not reach or it is listed at a letter serial number I may be permitted to mention who can stop any or senior please o 367 police protection I direct your application to be considered to consider your application by way of this petition the petitioner has f for a direction to the concern Authority to provide adequate police protection to the petitioners and that family member and the family members of the petitioner number two it is the case of the petitioners that they you are in living relation Rel they are residing in living relationship and the family members of pts number two are against the fored living relationship and therefore they prayed for they apprehend some threat from them and therefore prepered an application to the SP Banas at palanpur had application dated 21st April 2020 23 and that application seeking police protection is has still remain undecided next coning the foret submission as the application is made long back in the year 2023 the respondent SP Banas Kata is directed to consider the application dated 21st April 23 made by the petitioners and to consider the same in accordance with law the decision taken upon the application made by the petion be communicated to the petitioners by rpad this exercise is directed to be over by 30th of September 2024 petian is disposed of it is clarified that this court has not gone into the merits of the direct on behalf of Mr sh a police protection application dated uh in the year 2023 as such still date no uh Direction it has not been considered by the police Ms uh it's a case of interfaith marriage uh the husband is a Hindu and Muslim wife application the representation made by the for police protection is the p number 12 where is your application uh m page number 12 Eng this is dated 28423 after year also you would require that how could you survive for a year we would not PR SE permission to withdraw this petition as the more than one year has since making an application for police protection is over is elaps and in between there is no UNT incident is reported with the Liberty to file fresh application as and when required 379 please M this is for police protection AS application is made in the year 2023 uh both are majors and they have uh married and just the application may be decided at this stage honorable provide you police protection why I not made him a party it has been addressed but like I I am only asking for the superintendent to decide I understand it is written in the represent you make a fresh application even otherwise your application is 14 month old please my Lord's Liberty may be reserved I I I follow my seeks permission to withdraw this petition with a view to make a press application seeking police protection if at all required permission has prayed for is granted is clarified that this court has not gone into the merits of the matter and if and when the application seeking Poli protection is made by the petitioner the same may be decided in accordance with law please oblig this application for the police protection but I request for the withraw this application because they both living together at you want to withraw M Patel upon instruction seeks permission to withraw this application permission has PR for his Grant h please yes Mr police protection representation is on page number 22 you are not clearly audible Mr R presentation is on page number 22 and marriage agreement is on page number 13 onwards Bel by of this petition the petitioner is seeking direction to the respond number two and three to provide police protection to the petitioners therefore for that an application was made on 8424 by the petitioner number one number one and the S application has still remain undecided considering the long pendency of this application interest of Justice would serve if the SP banasa at palanpur is directed to consider the petitioner application and decide the same in accordance with law and decision upon the S application is communicated to the petitioners latest by by of RP by 30th September 2024 with the fored observation without entering into the merits of the matter the petition is she's show me that you have made an application to the concern police station um Miss Palmer seeks permission to withdraw this application with a view to make fresh application seeking police protection if required as in when the S application is made the concern Authority is directed to consider the same in accordance with law within of 2 months from the date of reip of the application and communicate the decision to the petitioner by of RP with the fored observation the petition is disposable this L said that if they may approach because it's long seeks permission to withdraw this petition with a liberty to file fresh application as and when required permission has PR for his granted great here my Lord coordinate bench instruct me to file the undertaking I'm for the respond from whom they have afer so I already file my undertaking that we are not approached to the we are not approached to the petitioner you will not approach the petitioner we we already file our undertaking which is already in file your Seri number and then after 61 yes seek note please La by of this petition the petitioner has read for a direction to respond number 224 for impartial investigation and to direct them to provide police protection to the petitioner for that petitioner made an application to DSP palanpur at banasa on 21st August 2023 though the man the matter was called out learned advocate for the petitioner was absent the record indicates that in between nothing Untold has happened the it can be presumed that during pendency of this application nothing unts has happened as the advocate for the petitioner is absent and learned AP also could not point out anything in view of that as the application seeking police protection is made on before almost a year on 21st August 2023 the same is disposed of with a liberty to the petitioner to file fresh application as and when the petitioner requires police protection permission is p is disposed no 87 by of this petition the p has prayed for a direction to respond number four not to harm or harass the applicant in any manner and to the concern police authorities not to register any offense against applicant number two next the petition was preferred in the month of December 23 when the matter was called out learned advocate for the petitioner was absent on perusal of petition I find that on 23rd October 23 the petitioner has written a an has made an application to the SP banasa seeking police protection when the matter was called out learned advocate for the petitioner is absent and nothing adverse could be pointed out by learned AP indicating that anything unts has happened in between in view of that the present petition is disposed of without expressing any opinion on Merit but with a liberty in per of the petitioner to file fresh application seeking police protection if required p is disposed of for number 28 this for Del of condition in a matter which condition condition number m is on page 11 mark his presence before concern police station in the first week of every month until the trial is over yes what is wrong in that after after after this order we filed a CR petition in which uh uh further investig further proceedings of the criminal case was State and as such I am broker and I required to travel out of station frequently further proceedings are stayed condition of bail are not St seeks permission to withdraw this application yes mrly the successive application page 22 is the last one page 22 22 by which know the trial was ordered to be expedited that order was passed on 6th of March 24 not even six months the position is as it is there is not even charge frame there are in all about 22 Witnesses the charge offenses of the having cultivation of of 3 and half kilo principal accuse is already considered at whose instance not this was done principal accuse is already considered at whose instance this was cultivation was made and he was being an owner is Jam Jam see the chart on page 20 ndps thep ACC no change of circumstances less than two years in fact the quantity is 3 kilo it is not it is not even commercial one in a case where some of the orders passed by theable Apex as well as by this I one order on find on page 30 30 30 yes that but there the quantity is 36 kg maybe you also may try after two and a half years there is one order by this L itself would not be considered as the that is on marit you the change of circumstances on Merit you have failed once yes yesing to the nature of the quantity inv found that is onit this also success maybe noorder which yes that was also success before of course the cour has granted Liberty not to come after the recording of the evidence of punch business what want maybe and for consider charge is not yet maybe what is change of circumstance I believe you there is no change of circumstances what do you want I her learned Advocate Mr assis Dougley for the petitioner Mr Dougley by of this successive bail application the applicant has prayed for enlarging the present applicant on bail in respect of offense registered on so and so so and so and so and so the last application for bail last successive this application successive application R Chi No Sir application earlier the petitioners earlier bail application were withdrawn and the last application seeking bail being criminal missous application number 787 of 2024 was withdrawn by the learned by learned advocate for the petitioner on 5324 within a period of 6 months without there being any change of circumstances this application is preferred by by the applicant next learned Advocate Mr Dougley points out that there is no progress in trial and that is the only circumstances on the basis of which this application is preferred next considering the fact that the offense is registered on 4th December 20122 an earlier application was withdrawn by the petitioner on 5324 today in absence of there being any change of circumstances the present application cannot be considered and the same is accordingly dismissed yes Mr boot 258 is your Lordships earlier order that after protected Witnesses are examined the your Lordships permitted me to appear but this was heard at length after the Supreme Court not the had also said yes and now all the three Witnesses are examined therefore six months have pass and what they have say uh out of three two have said that there is no telephone call between me and uh the principal accuse so I that is not there the third Witnesses have said in examination in Chief but he did not say so in his 164 state that contradiction has come and 164 statement is exhibit I'll issue notice next Friday sir five years he's he's been in jail for almost five years and all other except him all others are released on 13th notice returnable on 13 September 24s right there are two orders which I could look at know that the identical F the weight is 17 kg it is over now it is considered just to bring to the is over here it is 3 Kg is pass 2 230 will not be possible pass Passover is not possible Mr is on his legs before it will I'm not doing it you know it next Friday next Friday next Friday if 2:30 is possible not possible other matters are kept next please this is the matter where of the 420 and 406 ultimately the allegations against the petition Aries of 26 lakh rupees that he has cheated now there after what would happen 19 lakh has been already deposit rest of the 7 lakh m he has it was been Fe by the bank and it was lying in the account so they have filed the mudal application the petitioner has given objection regarding that so now no any amount has beenal application is pending before which court gnfc court as then when it decided I'll issue notice if he gets back the amount I'm keeping it pending otherwise my Lord today that application is pending ultimately if he gets the money there'll be change of circumstances merely preferring application cannot be said to be change of circumstances I'm not asking you to withdraw this or to file a fresh application and keeping it pending please my Lord otherwise one more if honorable Court gives the time to the present petitioner that 15 to 20 days after releasing he may deposit the amounts conditionally bail like that that be app come with that undertaking undertaking I on next Friday I will come with the undertaking 13th a week more otherwise my Lord that would be decide then the money will be transferred in the bank also therefore if the transfer in the bank account that I will come with that detail otherwise my will file the whatever 13th 13 I please yes this is regular B after tractors yes very is undertaking if they ready and willing to Lord he's not in a situation to pay any such amount he sold in his family relieving his his widow mother one children and his wife and see sympathy could be the last ground to consider application for bail but uh he full in his family and since 23 November 2022 he is in judicial custody yes he's at the right place at the most I can expediate the trial that's it uh these are some concern judgment which are relying on the condition of deposit of any such amount I'm not asking you to deposit anything I'm on gravity to gravity of offense in other matters if you go through the order the concern Advocates upon instruction and on sweet wheel and on their own valtion they own I don't ask that you deposit tax I not Recovery Agent it's between Finance Company you and complant what is the change of circumstances 8 20 lakhs yes gravity of offense ch yes L should but all parameters parameters to consider the bail application one of the parameters is gravity of offense as well you will find judgment on that as well but 17 accuse are also already 17 are enlarged on the basis of their willingness and their act of paying back the entire amount and still they will be facing trial e what do you want not if you want time I'll Grant you time except bill I can grant anything with these FS six sometime when do you want September October whenever you want next week I don't mind keeping it next week I don't mind keeping it tomorrow also or Monday I don't mind keeping it next week but on next week again you will ask for time if that is so take as much time as you want lot of guys called think speed whatever called time Things N I am prepared to conduct the matter today itself I am not seeking adjustment you are seeking adjustment that's it 20 L 20th upon request made by learned advocate for the petitioner s 20th any other matter rest of the matters bail are over police protection over if anyone wants their matter to be taken up I'm here yes 72 72 there is a 498 a questioning in this matter page number 12 starts Mr R you also want your M to be taken out with serial number you give the cheat so that pleas file can be husband and wife was living separately from last two years after two and a half years the F was filed this fi looking the condition is just page 11 page 12 C 12 C peti is preferred by whom uh PR preferred by the husband the mother brother Kaka s and taes okay so all five accused persons all five accused persons laips uh may I read the conditions of there yes leared Advocate Mr shiam tuer sham tuer for the petitioner M tuer points out that in the F itself the complainant has stated that since last two years she's residing separately at her Parental Home and therefore the f is registered belatedly and there are allegations General nature labeled against the PTI number 22 five and there are false and Fess allegations against the PTI number one next coning the fored submissions issue notice to the respondents returnable on so and so date in the meantime there shall be Iden in terms of per 7 B direct service permitted fls grateful o the domestic violence complaint present applicant are the father-in-law and mother-in-law mother-in-law is at both are senior citizen and the allegation against and the marage pan is very short only six month marage pan marriage was Sol n is the month of May 2023 and wife has deserted the home in November 2023 see hardly stayed the for six month at the her matrimonial house and allegation is very general in nature uh par page 30 Par 3 six line learned Advocate Mr hes Rupa for the petition Mr Rupa points out that the petition is filed by father-in-law and mother-in-law of the complainant against whom in the proceedings under domestic violence Act there are allegations of General nature and therefore the same are abuse and misuse of foress of law concerning the fored submissions issue notice to the response returnable on so and so date in the meantime there shall be Iden in terms of par 7c 7c direct service number two through concern police station for number one learned AP waves the service of I'm grateful to yes ising to this mud which something different I wanted to point out since I'm here 230 there is one matter which just fix very well this is pertaining to ndps one complaint was filed ndps I'll consider it in the month of October I'm I'm just yes my the applicant f is in 200 and what is the mud that is what interest because they say entire thing L kindly see the Sher report if my it is there in the memo itself page what I issue notice notice return otherwise page six may be seen sir my bank accounts checkbooks everything is been and all transactions of that accounts have been seed they are worth rupes lakhs rupees gold I'm issuing notice I'm not dismissing the P notice returnable October direct service short not be possible one thing which I may point out 27th September watch I may just point out two of the accus have been passed away the rejection order before the trial court is that one of the person is abson now that the trial court is kept the matter on 9th of September there are most likely that it will be separated and the order may be passed so that order I come if that is done then it is my are giving 277 great notice is SED upon the father on page 25 copy of the F where the petitioner who is Major the f is by the father on page 25 for the incident at to have been occur on 7 to 23 is 2 yes Lord under Section 380 of IPC stating that when daughter has left she has taken away one gold chain and Cas ofes 35,000 before registration of this father Yes and on 16th the Char is not F not no on page 16 before the F father has file Corpus petition before this court on page 16 wellar advate Mr mahj for the petitioner at the outside Mr mahes pujara makes a statement of instruction that though the F was registered on 5323 till dat Char sheet is not filed according to Mr pujara as the present petitioner did not obey the as the present petitioner married to some other person on page 24 marriage certificate who was not liked by the family members and as she married against the wish and will of family members a false fi is registered that the present petitioner has left the house by stealing the ornaments for rupes 85,000 which is not the case and the s f is registered out of Vengeance next concering the fored submission as well as considering the fact that the present petitioner has already married to page 24 one m by one mahes by parot by Mali parsotam by Mali on 1422 1222 that is prior to the date of registration of aair Prim the submission made by Mr puara seems to have some Force accordingly issue notice to the response return returnable on so and so date in the meantime there should be ID in terms of par three C direct service notice is has not appeared the notice upon the rule by of ident it is 3B please obl to Great direct fored please this is about the direction of the F direction to register F please may I request to refer page 23 application dated 30th 4 20123 La 30th April 2023 April 2023 address to Police Inspector GC Police Station Police Inspector GC police station bar Serv yes Mr Tucker I 86 it's a very small issue where threat have been given mobile phone it's a it's a very small issue the threat was given in the mobile phone and because of that an fi came to be registered lot third learned Advocate Mr patan for Mr jabala according to Mr patan the f is registered in respect of an all threat given on mobile however though the threat was allly given on 8 10 2023 for Which F was registered on 91023 nothing has happened in further of thefor said threat and therefore the registration of f is abuse and misuse of process of law considering the fored submission issue notice to the respond returnable on so and so notice already been ISS notice is already considering theate submission as despite service of notice simply ad in continue till further order yeah in I granted earlier to continue till further orders this ising to registration of f Lord application is on detail earlier The Honorable court has passed order once in spite of that there is no progress even no information P 47 go for private complaint but the last time Mr does not with in a minute page 47 page 47 that but they have not complied with the order of this honorable code page 47 then file contempt same order you want an order then I'll reject it in a minute my there I have already Mar the prefer the reminders and everything that that may be considered therefore no go and will the alternative remedy seeks permission to withdraw this petition with a view to Alternative remedy it is clarified that this court has not gone into the merits of the matter and withdrawal of this petition shall not affect the Merit of the matter in a minute page page last page page 62 where on 98 2023 I have already made a of the representation along with the order of dishonorable again and again it can't be done but the if they are not not complying the order of thisable C then then file then file contempt I not in contemp jurisdiction next contemp my Lord there is no specific time limit has been given that is the our difficulty therefore then go for private complaint I I will yes M vandra yes request for direct sir direction to application dated application dated 14th June on page 28 address to sit am why sit permission to withdraw with a view to make an complaint to the concern police station permission has PR for is granted I can also request for respond but fres application5 dispos you can't every time try to involve sit to make the off they have addressed the letter to the sit but they're not taking action that's why sit cannot take any action directly you will have to approach the concern police station even the letter to DGP was also written that was absolutely unnecessary unless you write a letter to concern police station no a Authority would be in a position to direct anything of M the are little bit complicated the borrower has expired if it is complicated let them take instructions here my Lord I will just app that subsequently after the death of the main borrower the insurance amount was given there thereby my the petitioner bank has uh recovered its due man and uh the one of the order passed by this honorable code where by my Lord the borrow borrow was allowed to uh take cust M of the mil card that is the order so if that order may be continued she may be allowed wife of the borrower may be allowed whatever order is passed on 211 2023 will be continued let there be a report very otherwise my our are that I point Fair yes and if position is given we have not thank please I other side is not there there father-in-law and mother-in-law they are residing 952 kilm maybe but in absence of other side I will not take up the matter in that case may 230 or any other shorter date not shorter date you may contact Mr tell after please any other yes Mr I were to pass order at 3:30 I'll pass it now in this my Lord press notice may be issued through rpad because police are not serving 151 issue fresh notice to respond number two to be on the fresh address which I provide to leave to amend the title already granted it is already granted yes also fresh notice fresh notice to the respond number two to the newly provided address in addition to normal mode of service petitioner is permitted to serve the respond number two through rpad because there isable high now I cannot issue RPD only Department can issue therefore I say at the cost of petitioner o yes yes Mr Patel 204 M 204 and 206 yes what is the mudal the mudal is the vehicle mys eco car 20003 166 not say once I said that I take up this m at 330 does not mean that I should sit idle in the chamber if I'm there 166 so that they can get the file in proper manner please which is the vehicle e eco car my Lord 204 eco car valuation 3 lak rupees 3 lakh rupes and the another is 206 is is the i i 10 car the valuation of the 150 150,000 I 10 150,000 206 o obl Max matter 207 I'm I understand everyone would be in a hurry to leave the Friday 165 83 yes please all the registration of f uh the officers has beaten the present applicant brutally where the one F was filed on this on the basis of that F the officer said that the complainant's brother might be the accused so they have take uh they have just called them and beaten brutally application dated 23rd November 23 address to DSP PN taluka and District PN investigation to be carried out by the officer of the CER of dysp to be supervised by DSP himself dpsp whoo Z this is the registration of f registration of I given application on 2022 my land I given power of there I given application thisable look at page number 31 39 this honorable court has passed the order to make an inquiry also because you kind look at the only one one minute page number 39 first yes please now kindly look at the page number 18 this not has himself stated in his statement that there there is a false p number 18 wa wait please my land has been taken up by other people without without my what happened to this order 21st February 2 nothing has been done even wait notice returnable after two weeks direct service permitted take the instructions even out of the bo I my counterpart has talk with a police officer even I'm having the recording of that even he was demanding something else that reason now he want to go with you may file a further complaint for that please please I will take direct direct service of M Mahindra bolo pickup it is in the animal cruelty all are live animal value 261,000 Bank guarantee Bank Guarantee Bank guarantee 2 lakh 61,000 2 lakh 61,000 Mahindra Bolero sross Valu xoss Isel diesel diesel diesel diesel wait Mr prajapati is waiting since last two months I also my Lord diesel diesel diesel wait at 2:30 it's not and now in view of Supreme Court decision 1994 Supreme Court say it's a state liability if I refuse to accept they have to pay the entire amount what would be more Prof and every dayes I have to you take instruction about that person should not suffer unnecessarily this is notel It's a petroleum hydrocarbon which I imported in a lighter way pre-conviction punishment [Laughter] I a short date so that they can two weeks I'm please inste analu animal cruelty much Bank guarantee applications mahra valuation MRA bolo 3 lakh rupees the tataa motors the amount is valuation is of 15 lakhs Tata LP 15 L Motors LPD LPD motorcycle truck truck whe truck whe truck truck it is truck truck Tata truck 15 L offense prohibition prohibition valuation is of 10 239 what is the mudal truck number GJ 25 7209 10 lakh Rupees it's huh maruti Suzuki maruti Suzuki Eco 350,000 valuation maruti Suzuki EO 350,000 rupees iser truck 6 lakh valuation 331 iser truck 6 lakh six lakh six lakh valuation 31 any other mentioning serial number 225 for mud 225 for mud 2 lak T Sumo 225 Tata Sumo 2 lak rupees number of condition my for is one alterate requesting you will have to go there I will have to but instead of every month my make it three or four months will take I am attending the trial to is will have to go serial number 162 sir it is for mudal but mudal is cash cash edun and where is your Amendment next week come with Amendment comp shifted to other address I'm requesting to be give the address is the address you address next week come with amendment number number 143 instru to replace number 35 that is a CF for delay for restoration because of non removal of the office how many days delay 66 days number 35 by of this mainor by of this application the petitioner has PR for condation of delay of 66 days in prefering application for restoration her learned Advocate Mr jiger ra for the petitioner and learned AP Mr so and so coning the governments made in the application and submission made by learn ADV for the parties as sufficient cost to condone the delay of 66 days in preferring application for restoration is made out the same is condone main restoration application third learned Advocate Mr jiger ra for the petitioner and learn Mr so and so by of this application the applicant has Tred for restoration of the main matter which was dismissed for non- removal of office objection Mr R assures that office objection shall be removed within a period of 3 weeks from today accordingly in view of above statement made by Mr R the matter is restored to its original file with a condition to remove the Office objection within latest by 20th of September 2024 failing which without any further reference to this card the matter shall be dismissed for removal of objection may I mention s number 73 petition will not survive my the complaint has been withdrawn 73 learned Advocate Mr n places on record auris order it's an order which is placing on record an order dated 20th of April 2024 passed by learned jmfc into bracket Main rajot in criminal case number 9841 of 23 whereby the present applicant is acquitted by placing that order learned Advocate Mr Desai states that in view of above order the petition would not survive and same may be disposed of as having become infructuous is disposed pleas request the registry there is some Revenue record there is very old year after 38 years yes you will have to get it t one concern cing petition circulation for on beh of advocate that also rejected request the regist yes there is the order immediate outside Raj outside R because nonexecutive traffic or yes there is aanch where will some nonexecutive post will be transfer from immediate my the pro and so far as part of there police commission will issue a circular no police officer will indul in land transaction matter unless any discl on theing of what about civil matters are pending and then there is an aspect element of forgery like that if fality is there then only they will have they will have to bound to be as cognizable offense but those matters where there are there is no element of criminality there they will not that circular which will be effective If instead of that it will be more which will cover entire District of the r but that will not provide for any punishment of nonadherence to that circular suppose if despite that circular someone registers the F then what will you do what will be the mechanism for that and and if that is so where is Mr Jani you swe the side he was feeling scared in sitting with him in this matter otherwise we are together and but then why rajot not entire Gujarat this commissioner will not be able I will be at my end I will look into it that that that is possible it will be that will save many people from the unnecessary only for information circular is already in existence issued by home Department issued by Direct General police and issued by these Court directions by my Lord Justice Z J as all these things are existing but even then this is going on I'll put that on record if necessary so it's more about implementation than it is matter to matter orders are passed that is a general order passed in similar similar such situation see why many more petitioners like this must be forced to run to this court investigating about transactions of cres of rupees I don't want to add the fuel to the fire not in my interest also but I nxd pictures today they are standing with police there on the L very I have pictures p in theft or robbery of CCTV C why police should protect the possession of the land then he is not found in possession by the Civil Court no I not on stay I am just pointing out what do you say Mr Jani are you consenting for St why why so what I am about this F this is all your creature creation rather then why then why should I not observe something against your client if I pass the order I record the consent that neither learned PP the manner in which the investigation is conducted nor Mr Jani have any objection if the FI stayed no okay then why why if you you do not have any Authority then why are you appearing for such client yes yes consent first you are you will have to are you an officer of the Court first or uh then perform that Duty since yesterday I I Cann no no yesterday evening you made so many forceful arguments yes I wasand all these are are your creation you have filed this F you have moved application after application you force the police authority to do all this then why are you shying from giving consent gance your grievance was of civil nature you dragged everyone unnecessary to all these litigations who will pay the cost of this litigation your client take instruction yes it is pointed out by learned PP Mr learned PP Mr hardik D assisted by learned AP Miss meta upon instruction makes the statement that IO shall be transferred to a non-executive post during the course of day as the leared senior Advocate Mr NTI appearing with Andy NTI appearing with learned Advocate Mr Asik dougle has questioned the manner in which the investigation has been carried on carried out in respect of all a for a small offense and a mole out of and a mountain out of mole is made out by the io the fored statement is made it could not be pointed out by learned PP that though the civil litigation was pending and some orders were passed by the Civil Court despite that the manner in which the investigation has been carried out was required 4.2 paragraph of the petition and precisely Mr ntis NTI by pointing out to the averments made in Para 4.12 next as learned PP Mr the way of an instruction does not invite a resed order issue notice to the respondent returnable on Tuesday that is on thirr 3rd September 2024 in the meantime there shall be Iden in terms of per 11c learned Advocate Mr pratik Jani Wes the service of notice for number two learned AP Miss MAA Wes the service of notice for State I'll dictate Mr Jan's part once he takes the instruction and if you are required in any other court if you are also required you may go Mr I yes see your intention may be good but implementation also should be strict enough you are not holding anyone responsible who flouts that circular then what is the point in issuing such circular the mechanism which can be circulars can be effective Implement yes and that can be done only by taking Stern action against aing officers by transferring them from one police station to another it will not yield any result Mr yes you may this is the additional EP copy of produc look's at page 37 check all are check transactions one is gpay transaction other all others are check at page 37 yes this complainant is present complain should be available online she was that's fine that's okay Mr for respond number to original complainant Where is the complainant this petitioner only learned advate Mr J appearing for the original complainant respond number two hearing also does not have any objection if the investigation is stay cooperation petitioner in view of that not only serious that will be considered on case to case basis yes what does it indicate anemic condition so I have to defer the earing let there be it's only 12 or 14 week old Fus uh as per the report 17 week then still up to 20 week it's permissible so I take an instruction and she is having pneumonia therefore as on Dat the doctor the panel has not given it will be kept after one week subject toia canc after two weeks last line will be given pranal termination prancy will be given after enia correction and anemic means weakness supplements or something and there this might be requ to be the time she's given something yes so for a week or 10 days as specific time as of now in view of any condition of the victim reported by the report of the medical superintendent zidus Medical College and Hospital D dated 30th of August 2024 upon request made by learned Advocate Mr Sony for the petitioner matter is adj to today we are on 30th so I'm keeping it on 9th ninth I had to produce the accreditation certificate most have taken sense CLS can have an K page 40 the newspaper was registered in the year 2021 page 40 oh accreditation certificate is something different not reg I'm pointing that application is pending that is what this was this was dated this was registered in the year 2021 after completion of three years of registration was I can apply that application I have made it is pending and an exure uh page 42 yes that applicationing and Page 44 this very Police Inspector malos himself has certified page 44 malos for to that communication this character since there are allegation in the second cross complaint mil against me that I was trying to save the those accused of prohibition and that is how the incident has taken place 186 complaint came to be registered this was my complaint which was that I was beaten in the police station and the I was abused by my cast that is what the complaint I'll pass that usual order number four DSP may be direct since the very P against whom the a SCP dysp dysp application dated 18524 address to Police Inspector Town police station viramgam be investigated by Officer of the rank of dysp Str ACP please my Lord last time directed them to here my Lord last time D orally directed them to lost the F lordship here the offense of 302 lordship the yes ma yes Mr pya where is the f hope you soon last time my Lord has put the query that why there is no blood in where Lord even they have explained this wise he was in Army their body strong therefore no blood that was their explanation you recording is with my client L when police officer himself has I'm not asking for papers where is the f why on 23rd on 148 this matter was Adent to 23rd on 23rd this was Adent to today why no instructions are there no Monday by today evening you will have to produce F fire bottom not bottom of the board 330 yes please every time you cannot take time that I'll get it done by next week this is a matter which has been filed in the month of January 2023 the FI is of the Year 2022 a notice has already been issued in the S matter the accused who is the who is named in the F has not been arrested yet your lordship and in spite he has prefered an application in the month of December 2023 an anticipatory B which came to be rejected I cannot force the police to arrest someone within some time bound schedule make application to the authority instruction does not press this with a view to kindly me for we had made a representation before we had made representation before the district collector as before the with aew to make a representation to the concern Authority if any representation is made the same may be considered in accordance with law as early as possible preferably within a period of one month from the date of receipt of the representation petition is disposed of his withdrawn next I leave yes Lear doit Mr Shang Tak upon instruction Mr way it is pointed out by learned AP Mr pya that f is registered on 20 where is the copy of 323 and 504 only two offenses it has been sent to Magistrate should searches who is the officer ask him whether he's registering the F or not yes then let Mr Japan come because this petition is filed after that on 61023 notice was issued this was registered in this was filed on filing is earlier buter come with Mr anure K page number 12 Police Station Police Inspector Sal police station application dated 5th of May 2023 5th May 2023 direct Service Direct service9 yes last page 70 number page is the order of the last application for the compliance of that order one order has been passed by the code in which but thereafter there is no any cive steps have been taken by the concern Authority yes the matter was starting from 2023 22 but thereafter there is no any even report has been submitted before where is your application my application is not anex there but uh it is on the page number 13 mil to register a complaint that is your prayer but pursu to which application pursu to the application of the this representation maybe kindly it is not an then make a freshh application last application I have permission to withdraw this petition with a view to make fresh application stroke complaint to the concerned Police Inspector of the police station last has taken place upon investigation if a cognizable offense is made out preliminary investigation the F may be registered in event if a cognizable offense is not disclosed then it will be open for the petitioner to prefer an appropriate complaint under section 223 of bnss before the concern magist I have submitted that application everything should be on record Mis so next last next I have not dismissed your petition you may make a fresh application unless it is pointed out to them how would they act in accordance may be adj I will submit it better approach them after a year I will not adj yes Mr Mish so this application is for registration of an f and uh sir in brief in brief sir uh before I file this application there are some seven orders to to this current application first magist first I went to police police did not register F then I went to magistrate magistrate declined then session s in that order sir then sessions sessions allowed remanded back then magistrate decline then sessions sessions allowed then magistrate magistrate declined then honorable Gujarat High Court honorable Gujarat High Court observed that it is very painful to see and then there was an oral remark I'm a oral remarks okay so we I leave it and seven rounds up till now against whom you have grievance sir there is an PSI now some brief history this was Mr Mishra tell me one thing yes sir why you see everyone why you see an enemy in everyone you have problem with police you have problem with court staff you have problem with the judges you have problem with everyone the other day you preferred a petition that your petitions are required to be reconstru are lost and therefore register F today you have grievance against PSI what is wrong with you sir the files are lost that is recorded by the order of honorable gjat High Court lost is see lost is right but for that why fi why pi and you are bringing unnecessary dragging all all this into litigation you should confine your grievance to the restoration of your application reconstruction so this is not that file sir this is a totally different matter I was beaten inside the police station and then this PSI has tended some 200 pages to this honorable Court honorable chief justice which when I sought through RTI the police themselves said that those documents were never do you think that ride PSI yes sir even the highest officer either beat police officer beat any other officer I officer would take a liberty to address any letter directly to the Chief Justice of this court or any other court no it was not in a letter it was in the proceeding proceedings yes proceedings if some reports may may have been called for he must have submitted there was a you may not have access to that it is mean for court not for you no I did not need it sir sir you said you asked for it in the no no no sir there was a Content proceeding against the same PSI same PSI in his reply tended some 100 200 some bulky documents I went to the same police station because he was removed by this honorable Court to investigate that matter further he was further transer reply was filed before the court yes sir you could have asked the concern court or The Advocate who was representing the pi yes sir to provide you the copy of reply if it was not reply or any other document you could have requested the to see that the you have access to those documents what is criminality in that sir that is not my gance my gance is he produced some documents which were not in his possession the court The Honorable Gujarat High Court had barred him for investigation he was removed from that police station after laps of one one and a half years being removed from that police station he had put that stamp ass Kar nakal when I went to police station saying did you provide these documents the police station up in all these seven orders the state has never said that we provided all these documents to him this is one aspect the second aspect is on 10th May 2021 I was beaten strangulated inside the police station I said please preserve the CCTV footage which is also the order was passed by this honorable court that preserve the CCTV footage and then I have been saying CCTV footage C but they are saying there is no CCTV footage when I go to police contempt so now this is not contempt if C reservation of CCTV footage yes sir was by way of a judicial yes sir right yes if they have not complied with that order what would be the remedy sir contempt was for DK basu's order sir not for this order contemp go something you can carry this also in contempt if you wish to no I don't wish to this F would be sufficient for me f yes sir for what I sir I was beaten inside the strangulated inside the police station there is an order of this honorable court that CCTV footage be preserved and that order is on anure sir I'll 7375 sir page number anex 10 7 page number 73 honorable Gujarat high court has you are appearing for this Pi yes rep I number of my to provide the copy the in the reply also iide every I provide I give a copy it is not being given I reply taken the stand also because he has made certain allegations which I not made to because the copy is not given to you you can Mr M provide it before five sir one small submission are you providing or not yes then provide it one small submission sir one small submission Mr Doug's friend Mr abishek we also said now it is provided one coffee is due for me he said yes definitely this conversation is some two months old I have that conversation it is provided to them full set you need that Mr Mishra I'll provide sir I provide than entering into debate provide it by five I take up the matter next week CH so maybe all next week so then we'll continue okay yes thank you sir 64 65 and four fourth 66 and 68 serial number 55 of Mr Japan D and Mr Japan d is not available may I request for next week not next week at the police not registered the F therefore the uh petitioner approach before the lended judicial magistrate Yip with prayer to register the F and full-fledged inquiry Al lordship the LED judicial magistrat rejected the my application given the reason your can you see the page number 32 yes may I read your L paragraph number six yes 32 please your order of the London judicial magist yes please this is the court finded the prim of fa the reason of the death of the disease has not kness with the story stated the applicant the reason of the this cour refusing the direct police to register the case in Alle offense the three folders number one the Alle incidence Alle assaulted on deis on so and so that not reported and second was reported your lordship after period of 20 days 26 days yourip the my mobile was lost yourip the leared judicial magistrate observed in this order can you see the page number 32 last two line for reporting death also you would require a mobile but cause of that your lordship he's assult he's given the threaten and due to your lordship this reason the they brother of the complain has committed suicide Yip the very where clipping is there in their mobile Yip that therefore the F was launched before the concern magist can see the page number 31 last two line paragraph y last two line uh for the first time 299 208 is almost after 26 days the reason for this stated that the complaint has found that the audio clip in a mobile the S mobile is also lost then yeah then after your lo I filed this application as a private complaint but leared judicial magistrate as a consider as a uh directed to L the complaint under Section 1563 your lordship this is not my prayer I have made the application before the concern m m learned magistrate the prayer with your lordship kindly see the page number 29 yes SA take instruction J please the short facts of the case this is a second petition earlier Direction was issued to the investigate this are third as such this is third round first application was submitted to di to further investigation it was done it was not properly done the for petition was filed further Direction was given it was not done the short facts of this Cas is like my Lord that one complaint was filed in 2014 my Lord accuse has committed huge fraud of CRS of rupees Char seed was filed for with regard 96 lakhs rupees only in that investigation the police officer went went to Bombay to arrest the accused person police officer has arrested the accused person during that arrest my Lord the police officer had already recovered huge amount of cash as well as gold from the accused person that was not shown in the Char sheet this is the case therefore this this complaint is against the police officer my Lord I rep very much please Mr B is there Mr B is in serial number 89 is there I I got the instruction that fi is registered already he's already registered but let AP May verify May requested this why Mr B appears for Mr ramani yes yeah Lord then according to learned Advocate Mr anaria as per the instruction received by the advocate for the petitioner the f is registered and therefore this petition has become infructuous accordingly the same is disposed of ASC I'm grateful thank you the application is of page dated 1810 2023 which is on page number 16 the contention of the applicant is this wi that both applicant and wife the accused paren were residing separately since last 17 to 20 years only for the reason that uh her daughter they had a child her daughter was of a marriageable age and that she can get a better groom they had both decided to stay together for a limited period of time in that period of time when the respon when the accuse came to know application dated 18123 only one month before this wasil Police Inspector m city a division police station yes near G there's a specific incident that one police officer has also came to the house he was sorry seeks permission to withdraw with a view to O appropriate remedy available to the then only may I request at 5:00 I will mention no then I'm dismissing it that mention then it will be is over please please is not she's not joining where is Mr mean not for resp respondent reply is fed they are saying that four and three have to register the F in the reply they lawyer is common for all the wait till Mr Amin comes please next week or a week thereafter very please may pray for next week some date will be given depending upon the number of matters he's not there please this was heard in detail may see the all year order dated 18th April 2024 where notice is issued specifically directing them to place on record the report thereafter before my lords also this was pointed out this relates is the report pursu to the a 18 c crime was handed over the inquiry I have given my statement C crime has undertaken the complete investigation they were to place the answer scripts of medical uh students has been exchanged and they have been declared pass apart from every other irregularity and then P where is the report why not there oh yes but this preceded a departmental in please see page 57 departmentally the university when this was point about compliance of the order I order report so you even are you working under university Monday at 11 L grateful this is one addition page 21 will be SE and the copy is sent on page 23 to the concern inspector what is it about is about my Lord certain Promises of purchase of car at a price many components have been registered everywhere I'll direct them to cons that usual order will be passed simp application dat 2 5821 address to CP but also copy sent to polic concern policy inspector page 23 on numerous occasions I was called Mr tell me one thing you being the president of bar and since I tried today also I requested again and again pro career he simply refuses to talk take one more chance my Lord can call us we can finish it off it a two minute matter I understand you do the need forly grate after two weeks matter after two weeks even the comp wants that it should be put an into yes is ready to even foro some amount is all such kind of disputes is available in the compound itself even before filing this I tried again and again he said that Abus language us ET both should forgive and forget that is exactly what I requested today also twice please your the complaint before the sit L have been instructed that report been submitted before the S sit may consider the report by file Val concern police station the false persons have executed representing on my behalf and executing has s it thereafter the same they have already given an application to sit sit sit has called for it before the consum police I have been instructed that police officer has submitted report before the s that maybe consider as and also in none of the matter you are having instruction Mr P show me one matter wherein you had instructions mons then why all these officers are uh none of the matters where in registration of f is the prayer no officer is here and officer is is also not required instruction is required why you not got instruction internet order been passed report being called Monday 126 is the same 126 also next Friday but see twet that something is done pleasure I'm appearing for Mr ENT here the offense of 306 lordship suicide not was also there even video recording was also there no F was registered thereafter present petitioner referred application before this honorable Court anex B page number 22 is the order even though no communication has been made till today why 10 from 10423 till date f is not registered what SP part has done copy of that has been sent to him as well registed by next week I'm keeping it on Monday make a statement Monday where is the report this is the matter which was mentioned at 11 by Mr no no I just am pointing out today I found I just received the instruction see e in the meanwhile my Lord just see the certificate as I am on temporary B and it was really painful so I just got everything scanned you get it typed I will in temporary B so I just got the copies right yes extension I will get everything time place everything on record you also come with because except conversation with him I found nothing from your end next week only one thing I will point out they are so prompt on 21st after beating him up that they can file a complaint at 6:40 same day but they have no time to file a report before the court they take everything for granted KN fully well that in September if I don't suum the contemn petition before Supreme Court you place everything on record by of report they were waiting either for the rain or for my release or for so many other things I understand sir I'm calling for record I leave it sirce next f is registered or not that was the query Why by Monday tues and whatever you produce provide a copy to Mr CH first pleas yes Mr this is regarding the mud that is in the nature of cash Mal cash wait for some time vehicles are priority at present on the last occasion my keep it on 30 because Vehicles keep coming therefore cash is stuck up yes J together with 245 serial number it is a rival claim what the Rival claim of rival claim of mud scrap container first let first Undisputed Vehicles ET be released so that people may start utilizing it earning something start earning something and may keep themselves away from offenses this is the F of the uh October 2023 V worth R 4 4 has been stucked up I'm not adding it after Diwali it's a matter of one or two week next week sir not next week week thereafter ch can it be on some regular day possible very well regular day o is under the prohibition the am the as a the Trader I called for my Lord the rice bags my Lord by the transporter so rice BS so rice BS Lord today vehicle only vehicle matters are given priority only my it ISE to raining it was what is the amount of that Rice bags about N9 lakhs and that is what the bill is you Bank guarantee of that N9 lakh rupees M the I I ready to put out the property or something because cash is very difficult for me to arrange yes property property my I am ready for that sorry Bank guarantee immediately upon you suppose if you are convicted then immediately they can encase that bank guarantee no what I am as such Traders so the driver and conductor who are the main accuse they are also not mine they are of the Transporters employees of the transporter I am the one of the witness more more more particular otherwise I I do not have they don't object I don't mind take instruction if he's a witness and are struck then give it back is also filed now he's taking instruction after two weeks next week if other it will deteriorate due day by day due to Heavy Rain that is 6:30 rice bags are there which is next 846 my property was given on a lease to one C Enterprise not related to vehicle right not vle some short May 13 yes we have to leave toen as section 37914 is not you want time vehicle eco car e valuation valuation is three lak rupes eco car three lakh rupees this is a Gold Jewel Gold Jewel gold wait o under prohibition maruti Suzuki Swift car 4 lakhs value maruti Suzuki Swift car 4 lakh rupes I'm MRA pick 2 lakh 50,000 4.5 2 L 2,000 Mahindra Bolero pick up vehicle 250,000 please eco car 4 lakh rupes H Grand value of the vle is Hundai Grand I 10 450,000 prohibition very 17 the Eco car 3 lakh eco car 3 lakh rupees Marti suuki espresso car 4 Lup marut Suzuki espresso car 450,000 L rupes 4 lakh rupes iser motor 5 lak page 19 iser motor 5 lakh rupes please my lord it's a boat it's a boat boat Val is value is .5 lakh 150,000 what is the offense prohibition V vot 150,000 much Honda SP 125 by 20,000 is a value prohibition Honda SP 125 bike 125 bike 20,000 is the value please to qualis three lakhal three lakh rupees prohibition offense Rea baj AOA and 30,000 30,000 dat tago car 3 lakhs rupees T Diego car 3 lakh rupees value of the vehicle 70,000 shy Tempo 70,000 Mahindra B pick up 5 L Mahindra Bolero pick up 5 lakh rupes eco car 4 lakh rupees marui Swift suuki 5 lakh rupes maruti Suzuki Swift 5 lakh rupees yes Mr patan Hundai Grand I 10 250,000 250,000 hyai Grand I 10 hyai Grand it 10 250,000 I'm sorry for the inconvenience previously maruti Wagar one lak rupees maruti Wagar one lakh rupees maruti bra 5 lakh rupees valuation 5 lakh maruti braa 5 lakh rupes page 3 38 of the punch number it is two wheer AC 15,000 50,000 15 15,000 15,000 Activa two wheer 15 15,000 mil the Royal Enfield valued at 50,000 one number of the registration is wrongly mentioned in the F correct number I have aned in the RC the is wrongly mentioned one digit of the registration correct Royal Enfield Bullet 50,000 that is Suzuki EXs 25,000 Suzuki EXs 25,000 t 4up T truck 4 lakh rupes car 3 lak rup chevet TOA car 3 lakh rupees Mahindra buo pick up tractor 150,000 Mahindra bolo pickup 150,000 pleas my lord it's Nissan mic car 70,000 value Nissan Micra car 70,000 plender Pro bike lot 25,000 Splender Pro bike 205,000 25,000 to Inova 8ak rupes Toyota Inova 8 lakh rupees Mr P you verified everyone has approach the trial court right yes Hond AC 40,000 Honda Activa 40,000 y y f by back side FZ second Yama FZ Bank 90,000 I did marud Suzuki ARA value is 6 lakh rupees Mar Suzuki ARA 6 lakh rupes for Eco sports car 4 lakh rupees B CA 40,000 rupees 35,000 pulsor 35,000 ofle maruti sft Swift sft maruti swift 4 lakh rupes please slender Pro 25,000 Splender Pro bike 25,000 fortunate 10 mod this is you are seeing 10 rupes it is mention in TOA fortunate 10 lakh rupes 7,000 70,000 present petitioner is finance company Finance Company then who was the registered owner of the vehicle Tata truck value of 12 lak rup 12 please Tata truck 12 lakh RUP only the FI number instead of 2023 2023 a draft mment is placed on record the same is granted to be carried out fourth with Mahindra Bolero pickup what is the valuation 3 lakh 3 lakh rupees Suzuki motorcycle M at 50,000 Suzuki motorcycle 50,000 mahra boero 250,000 Mahindra bolero 250,000 T truck value is 10 lakhs T truck 12 l 10 10 L 10 L my lord it's a Hundai 10 the value is 2 lakh rupees 2 lak 2 lakh rup Hundai I 10 2 lakh rupees it's a marui Suzuki Eco 5 Seer value is 1.5 150,000 marui Suzuki e 1 lak 15,000 Suzuki eak maruti Suzuki EO 2 lakh rupes maruti Suzuki e 250,000 maruti Suzuki for 250,000 it's a Mahindra XU 500 value is of 3 lakhs rupees Mahindra X 5003 rup vdi 3 lakh rupees Val marut Suzuki Swift vdi 3 lakh rupees please Lo which a truck 8 lak RUP Tata truck 8 lakh rupees a Tata Tempo 8 lakh rupees 223 Tata truck 8 lakh rupees Tata tempo right yes Tata Tempo 8 lakh rupe lender plus L is 30,000 Splender plus 30,000 maruti Swift 3 lakhs rupees Marti S 3 lakh rupees hondai AV scoa laip 30,000 Honda Aviator 30,000 request for next week Honda sign by L 30,000 Honda shine bike 30,000 for Fiesta Car 2 for Fiesta Car 2 lakh rupees baj Auto my one lakh Rupees to 1 lakh rupees Toyota Inova 7 lakhs Toyota Inova car 7 lakh rupes please B cnga 45 lakh th000 45,000 rupes Mahindra Bolero car 5 lakh rupes 234 Mahindra Bolero car 5 lakh 5 lakh rupes Maxi truck 350,000 235 Mahindra Bolero Maxi truck 350,000 350,000 rupes temp rupes as Len 10 lakh Rupees as L tempo as Len Tempo 10 lakh Rupees yese Mr it's okay you are much before time at least an hour early Hundai I20 car 3 lakh rupees hyai I20 car 3 lakh rupees please is TS Jupiter my lords valued TVs Jupiter valued approx 35,000 TVs Jupiter 35,000 prohibition with IPC 465 471 mil duplicate number was put on the car when the duplicate number plate was put on the car yes the original number as for the RC book yes Hundai I20 car 5 LS value y I25 lakh rupees I'm MRA valued at 450,000 Mahindra Bolero car 450,000 rupees EVS Jupiter 50,000 Rupees maruti Suzuki e car 4 lakh rupees maruti Suzuki e car 4 L 3 l 3 lak rupes Mar Suzuki Swift car 3 lakh rupees toyos 3 lakh rupees toyot itos three lakh rupees maruti Suzuki Zen esto 2 lak rupes maruti Suzuki Zen esto 2 L 2 lakh rupes 2 lakh rupees Tata hia dumper 20 lakh rupees Tata hia dumper 20 lakh rupees maruti Suzuki Eco it's a value of three lakh rupees maruti Suzuki Eco three lakh rupees any other mentioning rest of the mattress some date will be given next week leave it to him see difficulty all my PS are over burden because of this and there is no point if I don't if I'm not in a position to give you order in time or I'm reting the number of matters