XL Energy which is another really good utility stock that is very similar to Wisconsin Energy has the same kind of metrics if you will consistent earnings growth it got really highly valued you can just clearly see this would be poor time to be investing in this utility stock you generate no rate of return you literally have dead money for four or five years but yet if you bought it even in spite of all that if you were buying it at an attractive valuation somewhere in here even today after the big correction you be averaging over 9% and that's dividend and growth so valuation matters and it matters a lot