think sometimes on our show we tend to We tend to talk about things in a more abstract way or sort of a more theoretical way and I I do want to just mention that there are real Stakes here and that I do think that over time I do believe and I have hope that the rights of Palestinians will ultimately be one you know because ideally you know what we would do is is what Edward S called for years ago which we talked about in our episode on his book was you know one state solution there two State Solutions dead like that's not happening what really needs to happen is as a one-state solution which is prevent provides complete and equal political social and economic rights to both Palestinians and Israelis that's the solution and so you know there's a ceire proposal on the table Palestinians have already accepted it the US has helped sort of call that into into play to sort of orchestrate that and arrange some of that and of course the Netanyahu government's like no yeah um you know so I think it's very important to see who who's the real problem here now who's the aggressor here who's the aggressor here now and it's clearly the Netanyahu government