Motion de censure contre le Speaker Duval

the speaker is expected to lay aside any party or group affiliation on appointment and to refrain from political activity including voting in the houseand speak I don't even need to tell you I think you should stop this member Stay Stay within the parameters of your debate no no no stay within the parameters of said okay continue but within the parameters of said exact I've been L it's just a beginning wait wait wait I'll take a point over wait oh oh I cannot listen to five people at a time who want to go from for some fresh air I cannot listen to five people at the same time I think you want to go second time you want to go second time take some no no Mr he know all right I listen to your point of a and I recognizeable first wel come to you I refer to your ruling and I wondered whether you quote the date that this member is referring to Van v I need to say more or is it clear that she's not speaking within the parameters that you have clearly set that's why I just guided her to stay within the parameters I cannot anticipate what is in her mind yeah but but I don't know what's coming just give me a second allow me to listen I'll do I'll have your point of one second yes Mr I Mr Deputy speaker I moved that The Honorable member with draws what she said that the speaker will have to face a pro this has nothing this has nothing to do this has nothing to do with the conduct of the speaker during the time when he is speaker withw please I'm not asking you to withdraw I'm asking you to with a word with that is the word I don't like this yes I don't need you to go on Mage which didn't arise out of the conduct of the speaker in this Trumble do you get my point do you get do you get my point yes no wait wait wait wait wait wait wait wait right now I don't know can you substantiate it do you know what do you have anything to tell me that he's going to face it I don't know no no do you have something to substanti today no no what what I'm saying is standing standing I have to go back don't go over there go on continue but don't go over there with I have clearly paramet no no no no no no no no no no no no no no we what [Music] [Applause] I no no no [Music] no I I'd like to listen to you give you all the time all theway possible but these parameters as I've stated to leader of opposition I haven't set it out have I I haven't set it out you agree with me this parameter been here since a long time since 1980 and it's been five motion do you want me to change it now I cannot do that so stay out of it I'll listen to you you have if it's not the same thing please this I've already guided that I don't want to go there if you're going to tell me the same thing I'm not do is it the same thing let me read and then you will understand no no is it the same thing what I'm asking you yes Mr Speaker sir but over and above this 41 of these standing order say a member shall confine his or her observation to the subject under discussion and may not introduce matter not relevant there to that's what I've already told her [Applause] [Music] oh de allow me to get on with this speech honorable members no no no is becoming unbearable you always talking and allow me to do the job allow your friend she's from your par and she is that how you show her respect is that how you're going to show her respect by cross talking why she's talking support no supporting her in the right way not like in interrupting her she's already being right now and last warning I'm not going anywhere on the topic I'm minded to stop you completely if you so P me on please Mr speak sir my [Applause] CH oh oh oh next one I she talking is out next one I she talking is out wait please go for a walk next one who talk is out um no Legend Bo when I see I deal with whatever I have to deal right now there's no way that you dwell in a matter that has taken take please take a take a walk take a walk I'm listening you listening to me by no way you're going to introduce any of these matters that you've tried to introduce at least on four kid the fifth one might be fatal patri take some fresh hair I'm looking for next one to take some fresh fresh [Applause] you out and I'm ordering you you out to come back again for 15 minutes [Applause] H take some fres here don't come back straight away you came back in three minutes last time this time take six I need you [Applause] to no we stay on the debate no no take no no no no no hold you withraw this word and then take that is so good please withraw it speaker is Ed toay aside any party or group affiliation [Music] or no honorable members honorable members Pro am o TV news today I'm probably the youngest I'm probably the youngest I'm am o TV news here there are parameters there rules there there asking me there ruling there precedence what does it have to do honorable zaval have to do with motion of no confidence with the speaker I'm here just for job I'm not here for politics I'm not I'm not even considering which part I belong to I'm just doing my job please do your job all of you here at least work for this country we're not here to [Applause] play one second [Music] look M mam with all Jewish I hold to you I have a job here to do I'm Guided by books I haven't written them by myself I have a duty where the whole nation is looking at me and showing that I'm giving you adequate chance to speak I am doing my best despite you contravening all the parameters honorable Madam I'd like you to listen to me and have a little advice from honorable ad I'm working in the interest of your of the country I'm working to give you all the possible opportunities for you to make a debate in fact if you read my last line I wouldn't permit anybody reading as well clearly you're reading right now I'm not even going there I'm not being asked nasty as that what I'm suggesting is with all the patience in the world that's required from me let's work for the country within the parameters of the law do we do we agree do we agree on this one more one more outside the parameters one more statement outside the parameters I have set out I've work my way through leader of opposition and everybody please [Music] Victory arrangement arrang [Music] sitting arrangement louf you have to W one minute you have to wrap up we're about 17 minutes 17 minutes we are I'm checking the time sitting Arrangement an agenda unless you have something H honorable Mar unless you have something different to canas I minded to stop you right no we didn't do you have to convers wait sit Arrangement and try to do it within one minute please uh I want to listen to new point [Music] okay thank you or kalpana Kusha yes Mr Deputy speaker sir thank you and uh allow me to start by expressing very heartfelt condolences to the opposition condolences because it is clear that the the the die is cast the Coalition is inter stages and uh who was uh previously their best friends is now maybe uh honorable zav Jal has changed his col and they don't like the what do it have to do with I am bringing it into perspective with your permission Mr Deputy speaker sir here we are once again um another attempt another very frivolous attempt through this motion attemp no one second one second was that not enough that I had such a long conversation with you telling you stop interupting the business was that not enough I want you to reply to me please I'm recogn I have recognized you right now can't you reply me please please be respectful it's a tough job I'm having to do listening to everybody I I don't want to miss any point I'm trying to be as fair to the opposition and government so please help how many time can I keep on telling you this even little school kid don't do that please are we are we agreeable with this now are we please honorable member are we agreeable to this are we you don't want to talk now I hope he stays the same way honorable Minister do the motion do the subject thank you Mr deputy speaker sir to the motion another frivolous attempt by the opposition very desperate opposition who has been losing battle after battle on the ground and what do they do after such loss they bring their tired and tedious political scrubbles in the assembly and very right rightly so one of the members of my colleague from government earlier on reminded the the opposition that this assembly is not a political Arena I have listened to uh honorable Shakil Muhammad who is Fidel not present in the house who managed to shoot off the tangent of this motion and we witness his uh gesticulations very wildly making the leader of the House the the the the subject of his unwarranted and complete misplaced di tribe Mr Deputy speaker sir honorable through you I would like to to tell the honorable member honorable Shakil Mohammed that we have no lesson to learn from an opposition who have broken all records of absenteeism in this house honorable Shakil Muhammed is making irrelevant references again he's stepping out of the par which you yourself uh Mr Deputy speaker sir rightly put uh forward at the beginning of the debates of this motion he's he's making irrelevant reference to where the Prime Minister should be sitting for lunch and God knows what other criteria I mean I wouldn't be surprised it would not come as a surprise if uh if uh um the the new speaker would be blamed for today's dismal uh performance of the leader of of the opposition with his pnq fizet that we the leader of the opposition Inspire this is the leader of the opposition who is inspiring zero confidence in fact I congratulate The Honorable zavier ljal for having fabled a motion of no confidence because he he inspired zero confidence especially today during the pnq and I think the whole population got a chance to see that Mr Speaker sir the opposition who have tabled the motion of no confidence against the speaker the new speaker where was this opposition when this government this prime minister was busy bringing bills to this house bills to the effect bills that are going to be setting the scene for our future generations and yet today they were absent in case they don't remember where they were they were either doing uh press conferences outside this house or yelling in the precent of the the assembly today this opposition has the audacity to strut in here and table okay in all you right table a motion of no confidence again a new speaker who has been elected and dragged to this chair with all the uh provisions of the law being respected in fact we will remember that when the election of this new speaker was taking place again I repeat adhering to all the provisions of the law what did we not witness the population as a whole witness circus that happened on that day members who were suspended falsely claiming that they had received summons to attend that day's session which is a lie Mr Mr Deputy speaker Sir with your permission I am I am refuting points that have been put forward by the opposition we had we had members of the opposition commenting on where the Prime Minister should sit and have his lunch I mean there could be nothing more irrelevant to the motion than that we have we have witnessed um how the opposition who again through this very weak method or trying to to cling to some semblance of political existence maybe because through tabling a motion of no confidence against the new speaker and making frivolous accusation there are very troubling accusations that have been made in the house today Mr Deputy speaker sir and they're more troubling because of the total absence of evidence to support th those accusations you yourself have ruled uh against those uh those accusations today so Mr Speaker sir they are refusing to accept except one simple fact a simple fact that the people has already placed their faith in this government they have placed their faith in our institutions and they have placed their faith in this assembly when we talk about the assembly we talk about the legislative process we talk about the fairness we talk about the Integrity of the house we are talking about the integrity and the role of the speaker so the the the the the motion of of no confidence towards the speaker holds no water whatsoever Mr Speaker sir what has been spoken words that have been spoken here goes down in hanset it goes down on record but history is not only going to remember words history is going to remember actions history is going to remember what has been witnessed within the walls of this August assembly history will recall the absence I to be to to be very honest Mr Deputy speaker sir I don't even think that the seats occupied that by the members of the opposition ever had a chance to even get uh taid or even warm because they have never been here they're always absent Mr Speaker sir the opposition today is clinging is clinging to a straw they are drowning they have no substance they don't even they cannot even articulate a vision of Their Own like I said earlier on today this motion of confidence is the only way to have or it's either that or go and have uh um press conferences at uh every every minute and every hour of the day the you the new speaker Mr Speaker sir the moment he has assumed his his duties he himself has reversed some of the uh decision of the previous speaker Mr Speaker Sir Mr Deputy speaker sir the newly appointed speaker elected speaker has brought in uh Innovative measures about uh uh digital Innovative measures to be brought into this house so instead of uploading these new initiatives and we are talking about a a new speaker who has already carried out successfully and admirably well duties of Deputy speaker in the past so what we are seeing today Mr Deputy speaker sir is just another addition to the list of by the opposition of course another addition to the list of is no good when they are in opposition this is what this motion of no confidence it is the same the sole objective of that motion of no confidence Mr Speaker so they talk about respect they talk about um how the provisions of the law um was were not respected their own colleagues previous um speakers of this August assembly have come forward and said No in fact you members are of position you are wrong all the legal ways have been respected in the election of this new speaker so Mr Speaker sir I am not going to dwell too long on uh um on the the embarrassment that is the opposition and what they're trying to achieve Mr Speaker sir it is a motion that has resoundingly been rejected by the population who's following these debates resoundingly so I don't think there is an Iota out doubt that uh at best at best this motion is merely um applo to gain some political brownie points but at worst it is characteristic of the abor ploy of the opposition the opposition today has come to this house like I said to gain some uh political survival to obtain some serum to talk about I heard honorable Shakil Muhammed earlier on say papa p i mean how de basing is that him to withdra every no but he did make the reference withdra it is no longer part of this is the whole Mr Deputy speaker I speak under your correction before honorable Shakil Mohamed how many of the members of position have made reference to uh the new speaker being the son of a member of this Parliament wait wait wait I recognize you wait wait H Minister yes Mr Deputy speaker sir I ask him to withdraw I'm not cating any more referen to whatever it is worth okay Mr Speaker I got I'm coming to you no when I said Father and Son as opposed to the real version when I said father and son I never referred to The Honorable Le of the opposition I never said to speaker I meant sir anut and no no no no no that's when I withdrew it it's not a point of it's not point of it's a point of clarification go go on Ministry Please Mr Speaker sir thank you for allowing me to continue I am going to conclude uh but once again I reiterate it is not in order it is not proper it is not gentlemanly it is Unbecoming to make reference because we are all py of our Papas well at least members on this side of the house can claim to be PS of our Papas and uh I am of the firm belief that this motion of no confidence has only been brought to the table of this August assembly in an attempt of the opposition after the mm their leader uh of their Coalition having kicked out booted out um the the P from their Coalition like I said now p is no good Mr Speaker sir um when we speak about when we speak about emotion of no confidence when we speak about about uh the the the law According to which this Parliament operates the standing orders the National Assembly act all the laws pertaining to where we're sitting today it would have been extremely important before this other P of her papa of would have learned a bit have gone through done her homework before coming in here and purporting and and yelling outside the uh assembly that we are violating our Constitution and this is somebody who has recently passed the B we ask ourselves whether his B chashi has passed don't know so Mr Speaker sir allow me to uh very resounded and unequivocally say that we on this side of the house are definitely not going to be supporting this motion in fact I reiterate what honorable ganu has said there is no motion this is just a show there are some clowns who have thought that this Parliament can be turned into a circus and we will have none of that long live the republic ofous speak thank you thank you very much did I write here you said there is no clowns did you use your with clowns in reference should we draw it thank you m I withraw thank you very much honorable Mr Deputy speaker I'm going to be so cool you won't believe it I'm really looking forward to get yes we look forward because Mr Speaker this motion is so fizet it is even worse that the worst pnq ever that I've heard in my life this morning M this afternoon Mr Deputy speaker first of all I'm going to be very cool because there's not much to answer my colleagues or my my my friend friends from both sides of the house including Mr Muhammed have said what needs to be said some have descended below the Bell but that is only to be expected of the mmm Mr Speaker sir and also the leader of the position wasn't so so kind as he ought to have been nevertheless I want to congratulate Mr Speaker honorable adal I know that a lot of well thinking members here have not taken part in this debate don't be have not taken part because they have not wanted to be associated with this motion of the leader of the opposition most of them Mr Speaker the new speaker has brought a breath of fresh air like it or not that is a fact and the people of Maus realize that new speaker has brought Serenity and peace in this house which has suffered for such a lot of time I take my hat off to him he has been able to keep calm I would not have kept calm he have been able to keep cool I would not have kept cool even in the face of the most calamitous attacks that you can imagine a young man of 34 years old has never attack anyone in this house never be subjected to such demeaning words hurtful words from people and they are Ka Mr Speaker I will tell you why they Capo because they attack the speaker because they fear to attack the Prime Minister that is why they have attacked subsequent speakers because they fear to attack people who can hit back Mr Speaker I I said I would keep calm didn't I I'm sorry about that Mr speaker now you have said I think it was with the leader of the opposition you said that you will ask him to remove you will remove from an whatever has not been substantiated I therefore raised a few issues which have not been substantiated meeting there was in the north yes political meeting no not at all there were that was one meeting with the nfsm then there was another meeting where the were labor party there were some me these were sponsored activities by big firms have you ever seen people putting banners and then saying this is a political meeting there were civil servants there lots of people there and our speaker you should be there and he will be there Mr speaker now whatever some people may think what he has Shar some transport he has a car government car now he never Shar any transport even if he had what would have been the problem but here we have some B see what said transport who I'm not talking about anyone did I say anything any on any member I'm thinking outside of the parliament you have byi many by outside of the parliament and now he's even someone ra it in this house that the speaker has been talking in the ear of Mr RS I didn't know I found out who this Mr RS is this is this this is this is not true but this is a matter to bring to this house and I'll say this like I haven't talked to the Prime Minister about it I say though that this is some part of a deal it is not the prime minister to his credit never put any conditions with the appointment of the speaker Mr Deputy speaker sir to his credit I must admit that I was myself surprised by this he did not and I have the greatest respect greater respect because of that Mr speaker now the fact that horable Aras by the leader of the opposition who never does his homework goes and says in in in the Sou house that it is the new speaker who appointed who nominated honorable armas for a mission he should apologize it was done by the previous speaker the previous speaker he should have put he never does his soew work he comes and goes without ever doing any homework and and I will raise this hopefully inshallah if we get a motion my motion comes we will raise you have to translate in no I don't now Mr Speaker if you don't understand it I'm very sorry for you now cannot use a language outside I'm very sorry for if you don't understand it don't be sorry sorry about that for me you don't joke H with me you don't joke you come straight I am straight you come straight okay now my Mr Speaker these guys should be praising the new speakers should be praising him to the to to the to the heaven throwing of lots what have we not seen in the Press had a drawing of lots that was a CL with the old speaker were messing around with the with the venerable questions of these of The Honorable members and he changed it overnight from now on it's all clear cut like before did you hear the leader observ mention that that is bias that is what bias is all about now what about committee rooms The Honorable leader of the opposition is a champion of having an very undignified champion of having his his uh press conferences by Victoria statue and the new Deputy the new speaker thinking not of him but of the decorum of the house because he of the decor room of the house there should be back to where we were before have even though you attacking him calamitous attacks his his greatest of Mind use a committee room it's your previous speaker had abolished the need to do that did you see any mm this house thinking the third thing members have been named and so I've never been named since election hey I've come to some members have been named so many times and now can have access to the premises par there because use the library and I doubt if they ever use a library but use a library if they want okay now questions on local authorities it's juus whether it should be or not allowed but again in a spirit of good will let Let The Honorable Minister answer questions how many lwes are broken down as if it's his responsibility which is not but still he's now has to the minister has to answer now did you see anyone thank him the new the new speaker and of course Parliament needs to be brought into the new era of of uh of uh I think one member was talking about web now did not understand what it was with is no no but is what is happening all the time say speak and so bring AI use of AI to automatically translate what we are saying into French into English for the start bring AI so that people can question like you go on chat GPT and you question what is this what is that and you can go and question how is emotion prepared Etc so Mr Speaker these are things and Mr Mr Speaker he has given additional time for PN Qs when usess pqs are given additional time now given additional time never makes any point he never gets any point across but they given additional time to make a f of himself is also a truth speaker want me to withraw it I withdraw it I withdraw it no Mr Speaker the question was even allowed on the overseas travel of the previous speaker and these are things Mr Speaker that someone who has been attacked from the start and neveress gone and You' have seen him in the chair he doesn't have any miss any any anger against any of his members he doesn't have and this person Mr Speaker hearing all this rabbish people are talking about how it is hurtful to to hear that and thank the members of the opposition who have not taken part who have shown that they are decent people I thank them I will never cease to thank them even Muhammed was decent in his in in his in his speech and I thank him for that Mr Speaker I don't have the same words for the leader of the opposition Mr Speaker therefore he's done many things and this but obviously I mean there's a lot of theater the speaker lives a lonely life in the UK but that is the UK is the UK here Mr Speaker if the opposition today tell me that they will not stand against an Adrian juat if ever he stands in the campaign for election and he won't go anywhere but it's not the case is it they're not going to hear and say to Adrian jual you've been a speaker for a few months and we are not going to stand against you in the parliament now you are automatically elected why don't they do that they don't do that but they want the other side they want their cake and eat it they want their cake and eat it and it's not going to be like that they not going to be like that Mr Speaker then they say this the speaker has not the speaker lives a lonely life he must didn't go anywhere but have you seen the UK ever the spectacle that we saw here talking about talking about all sorts of horrible even ladies talking about that do you think that would have happened in the UK does Mr Muhammad tell us honorable Muhammad ever think that this spectacle would have happened in the House of Commons so you asking the speaker to hold up the banner of the UK speaker but at the same time here you people act as holigans as holigans cheap holigans Mr Speaker no it's not possible and I tell you this and The Honorable lead should know that if they thought they could attack speaker F here and nobody would answer it's not going to happen like this we're going to if the speaker you choose the speaker to attack why because he cannot answer back he cannot answer there's no nothing more cowardly nothing more cowardly in our politics that you attack someone who cannot you back just suspend you that's all you can say you go out that's it you've insulted him you've said but that's not going to happen like that this is what I put the motion next week hopefully I don't know when the Prime Minister f is going to come because it's cowardly and I don't like cowards Mr Speaker sir I don't like cowards now Mr Speaker Mr Speaker sir and what about engaging in politics what about engage where does it in which in which part of the law which was amended by the labor party mmm my father was leader of the opposition at that in 1996 which part of the law please show me I beg you that it says that the speaker should not engage in politics or should not be uh should not be a candidate we have had speakers candidates I was elected same as in Bou in ' 887 it was was and de was a speaker you could you you you should hear his speeches at that time against the M who are adversaries and still who are adversaries you hear speaker he has to you Deputy speaker they wanted to appoint you as Speaker would you then have said I will not ever go anywhere I will stay at home I will not that's outside that's outside okay that's outside of I'm not I'm not aware nobody approach me to propos me as a speaker speaker nobody approach me anybody I'm saying approach you Mr Deputy speaker but the honorable leader of the said so his speech he said so that's why I'm taking I'm raising if you had not raised it I would not have raised it then you're a member of the ml I think what would have happened then now why did we ask Adrian to resign from the instances of the party not because we thought it was illegal but we did not want him to come under the influence or the control of any member of any instance in the party that is why he not in the bureau politic because in the bureau politic you all have to listen more or less to what the leader says what the bureau politic decides he not there anymore he not in executive either not because he's not allowed to buy some law if if the then government wanted to make the speaker somewhere that is that would never stand again first nobody would take out the job especially not at 34 years old and secondly say they did not do it it's not in the law so don't talk about things that are not in the law now Mr Speaker let's go on some of the uh other issues and I will not be so long Mr Speaker there was this rowdiness here rowdiness here which was a shame which then they say well the deputy the speaker should never answer oh no no no no he must answer you go and tell him any rubbish Hees answer and I just mention one thing on this issue of drawing of questions you heard all the T that there was when they were invited and I know this from the government whip when they were invited to witness and they even put the Integrity of the clock into question and when they invited to come and witness the drawing of lots for questions nobody came they were busy twice not once twice two weeks in a row didn't come they were too busy Mr Speaker so now what about me wanting to move I'm not just anyone I'm not a proud person but I happen to have been a deputy prime minister I have 30 years or more in this house I was their revered leader of the opposition for six years Mr Speaker I'm not going to sit up there and someone else comes and sit in my place if as I understand the honorable members of the position who are I think in an I'm not true if they are in Alliance they would be very very happy to sit wherever they want they say it is communal because I am sitting behind the the the leader of the opposition I like if there's no eality this chance I cannot sit behind the leader of the opposition because it is communal is what they say all the time it's communal sitting Arrangement well swap between themselves swap let sit there next to his friend and so Mr Speaker don't don't don't dwell on no M Mr Speaker you must be clear on one thing they raised a seating issue many times many times as if that was the issue why this gentleman who never comes hasn't come I'm now I'm allowed to respond to this to say that they have been given the chance to move around they have refused to move around keeping the political Point like the questions that they have a problem with seting Mr Speaker so I know you're going to stop me in a moment I presume you're looking at your watch pause the time yeah it's pause the time I'll give you two more minutes okay now Mr Speaker there there has been I won't go into this there's one thing has been rais or in this house that I was rude to Mr Speaker Deputy listen to me I'm saying something good that I was rude to honorable bhan but honorable bhagwan did not say what he was how he was addressing the speaker who is in the chair you've heard of how the speaker should be apolitical but then members also I was rude to him and then out of my own valtion because nobody heard it I apologized I told him come and sit here he refused I was not upset with him but you cannot break the rules and get upset when your neighbor and I didn't even have honorable armor next to me I would have been fed safer I was alone but still I come and sit by I'm not against you but don't insult the speaker and then expect and get upset when you get up we get insulted so Mr Speaker I'll finish with this Mr Speaker sir just to say that people are attacking and I will say this I hope that uh honorable speaker is listening people are attacking the speaker not because he's incompetent not because he's lazy not because he cannot do the job but precisely the opposite because they fear Him they fear that will be too good for the job they fear that it may affect their electoral chances and they are they are they are willing to go to any any step down in the gutter if they need to just to protect their ambition to become some sort of government in the future and we need to make sure that this doesn't happen mrut speaker [Music] I don't know about you but I need a break for about 10 minutes e e e e e