I'm Not Buying The Rings Of Power's Explanation For Why Isildur Doesn't Destroy The One Ring In LOTR

uh what if the choices made by our favorite characters were not simply the product of their circumstances but the Dee rooted stories and traumas They Carried within them before diving into this exploration please consider subscribing to our Channel and giving us a thumbs up Bobby and take a seal deer for example a pivotal it often misunderstood character from tolkien's Rich lore and in Amazon's the Rings of power theal D's portrayal is more nuanced than just a side of character he embodies ambition compassion and the heavy weight of expectation but the reason he chose not to destroy the One Ring that's where it gets Tangled in itself in the series isor reveals a Melancholy chapter of his past his mother sacrificed herself to save him from drowning this heart-wrenching moment haunts him igniting a drive to achieve something extraordinary he aims to honor her memory believing that greatness must come from his efforts yet this longing seems tragically ironic as we know a seer's Fate One shrouded in infamy the show attempts to flesh out why a seal or clings to the ring it suggests that his mother's sacrifice fuels his desire to use it for good an intention that Echoes tolk's themes of tragic irony while this backstory adds depth the connection between his mother's sacrifice and his eventual downfall raises doubt about the reasoning being portrayed and a sealo decision to keep the ring after such a harrowing triumph over Sauron appears misguided why after slaying a dark lord would he compromise his nobility with such a perilous Relic the ring itself exerts a corrupting influence clotting judgment the added justification of his mother's sacrifice feels like an unnecessary hedge against the overwhelming pull of the Ring mathing must see who's one of the best Sons law the exploration of a sealer in the rings of power is engaging yet the reasoning behind his choices leaves room for skepticism perhaps like many epit Tales aelder story illustrates that the greatest battles we fight are often within ourselves on a lighter note have you heard the joke about the one ring it was a real catch until it lost its influence and uh with that said uh thanks for watching and until next time