Is Eli Manning a first ballot Hall of Famer we brought this up on the show I did um is Eli Manning going to be a first balent Hall of Famer oo I don't think he is a first ballot Hall of Famer type talent I certainly think he's a Hall of Famer but to me like you know I'm old school and that first ballots are like guys where it's like they're in a special oh Ray Lewis we don't have to think about it Lawrence Taylor no doubt about it John Elway what come on get out of here you're in your own special room Eli Manning damn good we know that right but there's a lot of other things on his resume that I think you could sit there and go well that's not first ballot Hall of Fame worthy can you be Who had a better career Eli or Dad objective and with the following question who had a better career Eli or your father well I you know I think Eli had a better career because he got to play in that second Super Bowl and win it right where my dad of course had a was hurt in week 14 in 1990 and then they went on and won the Super Bowl with Jeff H so I think that kind of gives the edge to Eli Manning uh yeah but your dad was a better regular season quarterback I think my dad was a better talent and a better player I'll tell you that I don't know if his career was good but I think when you get into the talent and the player and maybe the the talent he had around him on offense like most people my age can't name one receiver that played for my dad right you go through the Eli Manning Giants and you go damn it's one All-Star after another on wide receiver so so there are some things there that's good conversation Eli's career is better but I do think Dad was a better player I do I'll say that but if David Tyree drops that ball Is Eli Manning a Hall of Famer is Eli Manning a Hall of Famer well that's a good question I don't know it'd be we'd be right on the line there would be he C well he certainly shouldn't have been the MVP of the Super Bowl I know that for sure somebody on that defense it was the greatest offense we ever saw ever absolutely yes and and you know 1714 with Brady and Randy Moss and Wes Welker and crew that was incredible but uh we know Eli certainly had the clutch genan there's no question in that